I started reading this past week-end the Power Of Now, a book by Eckhart Tolle, and I must say that I found it very interesting and insighful, but I am wondering if the teaching of this book somehow contradict the way we are supposed to use the Law Of Attraction such as in the book Ask And It Is Given by Abraham-Hicks.

I am concerned by this because the Law Of Attraction, especially in the last month, has worked pretty well for me, but on the other hand, the book The Power Of Now is sort of mind-blowing for me.

In the law of attraction, the thought we offer all the time attract certain things and situation to us, and the law of creation is :


The answer is given

Allow (or receive )

However, in Echkart Tolle book, all thought are the results of us using our mind, in an egoeic way, and it leads to live in the world of dream, where we are never present, where we are never IN THE NOW. According to Tolle, we should use our thought as less as possible, and according the law of attraction, are thought are the base of creation.

Now since I am new to those concept, maybe my misunderstanding is ascribable to that, but I am wondering if those two teachings are incompatible in some way ?

How can we create if we never uses our thoughts?

Did using the law of attraction prevents ourself from living the Now?

Can we mix both principles?

Thank you!

asked 29 Jun '10, 07:43

Marc11a's gravatar image


edited 03 Jan '12, 08:03

Barry%20Allen's gravatar image

Barry Allen ♦♦


the audio book (power of now) was great. I think it is a great resource,as well as the printed text.

(29 Jun '10, 16:29) ursixx

Yes, one of my favorites along with 'A New Earth.' And 'Stillness Speaks' is a good meditation tool...

(30 Jun '10, 02:17) Eddie

Add your reading on The Power of Now to your statement that LOA works pretty well to you. It is part of the equation of your progress.

(09 Aug '14, 11:39) Romel
showing 1 of 3 show 2 more comments

Now since I am new to those concept

Once you have read the teachings from Ekhart, Abraham and others a few times and begun to intergrate those teachings into your life, you will see that there is no contradiction.

Following your bliss or excitement also applies to exploring inner space...


answered 29 Jun '10, 09:57

Eddie's gravatar image



Since I didn’t really say much in this answer, I’ll clarify here. If someone continually spends their time thinking of the past (regret) or dreaming of the future (hope), then they exist in a state of mental confusion. Not realizing the power of the now moment, they oscillate between past and future mental states. These states only exist in their mind, thus they are illusions which contain no power of their own. Thus, these people exist in a state of dis-empowerment.

(23 Jan '12, 21:29) Eddie

Learning about the power of the now moment means becoming self-empowered and from that state, one can consciously use the LOA for whatever one chooses.

(23 Jan '12, 21:30) Eddie

To my shame, I haven't read Mr Tolle's book yet. I keep stumbling across references to it time and again and it's high on my list but...yes, I know, I have no excuse for not reading it yet :)

Based upon your description of the idea within the book of living in the now, I see no contradiction between that and manifesting what you want, which appears to be what you are concerned about.

I presume Mr Tolle means Be Happy In The Now when he refers to living in the present, otherwise the idea wouldn't make much sense.

So, if that's the case, then he seems to be touching on the purest form of manifesting, which is...

Be happy (in the now) and you'll get everything you want

Yes, you don't even need to consciously think about what you want :)

See this answer for more insights about this idea: Why do we choose to use manifestation techniques as opposed to getting in the vortex?

The reason that Be Happy (in the Now) works as the "ultimate" manifesting method is because your desire is created in the moment that you want it.

As far as the Universe is concerned, your desire already exists once you've made the decision to want it. There's nothing else for it to do.

So it's really all about you gaining vibrational access to that already-existing desire.

And the only essential requirement to physically manifest it is actually to Be Happy Now because that good feeling in the present moment indicates alignment with your Inner Being / Higher Self which, if you've read the previous link, you'll realize is where your desire is waiting for you, vibrationally speaking.

Indeed, if you strip down all effective manifesting methods to their bare bones, aren't they all ultimately trying to get you to be happy in the Now?

And Now is all we have anyway, so actually there really isn't anywhere else to live but in the present. :)


answered 29 Jun '10, 17:58

Stingray's gravatar image


"Be happy in the now and you'll get everything you want" seems like a contradiction since, ultimately, people want the things that they think will make them happy. Consequently, if they can choose to be happy in the now moment, then they already have everything they want, and so by definition they don't need anything else.

(29 Jun '10, 19:17) Vesuvius

@Vesuvius - And that is the paradox of manifesting that has been mentioned on this site many times in the past. Once you no longer need the thing, it will come to you. The state of being of having the thing you want must always come first.

(30 Jun '10, 05:08) Stingray

You guys are good, truly just be happy. What good comes from fear, lack, and other not feel good thoughts

(10 Aug '14, 21:30) Tom
showing 2 of 3 show 1 more comments
  • Step 1 can come from ego ...yes

  • Step 2 universe immediately responds... Can't be more in the now than that!

  • step 3 our higher self ;it is the part of you that is not or has no ego.


The steps to deliberate creation (in Abraham-Hicks terms) are

  • Step 1: The question is asked (or desire is launched)
    • Step 2: The universe immediately responds with the creation of the vibrational potential that matches the desire or question
    • Step 3: In aligning our dominant focus regarding that topic with that of the vibrational potential that now exists as a result of the question being asked, we allow the answer to enter and manifest within our reality (i.e. we get our desire)

Step 1 occurs when we think about what we want, or notice the difference between what we have and what we want.

Step 2 occurs when we release the thought, and allow the universe to manifest it in the non-physical.

Step 3 occurs when we bring ourselves into alignment with our higher self, where the manifestation has already occurred in the non-physical.

There are many questions and answers on this site that discuss different aspects of this process. Those questions and answers can be found here: http://www.inwardquest.com/questions/tagged/reality-creation link|flag edited Jan 14 at 16:57

answered Jan 14 at 16:51 Vesuvius

Ps. I didn't know how to link this answer from the question


answered 29 Jun '10, 22:29

ursixx's gravatar image


thanks... noted

(30 Jun '10, 06:48) ursixx

Eckhard Tolle teachings are meant to facilitate theosis (self-realization also known as enlightement). Enlightement is moving beyond form and material plane because no true joy or fulfillment are to be found here . Any wishes and desires bind us to this world. Everything that you wish for will be given to you. If not in this lifetime, then in the next. Do you really want to come back here- in the world of wails and gnashing teeth ? Be careful what you wish for because it will come true :). I just wish to unite with Absolute Beingness and Abraham's teaching is helping my wish become reality.

Love to all.


answered 22 Aug '11, 01:52

sleepy%20hedgehog's gravatar image

sleepy hedgehog

The answer to this question is


Eckhart Tolle (The Power Of Now) and the Law Of Attraction are NOT compatible.

There are two movements in the universe. One is the outgoing movement away from source (like the big bang expansion), this is the movement of creating, becoming, manifestation, experiencing, desiring, building, more and more. Aligning yourself with this outgoing movement you will use the Law of Attraction. The other is the return movement back to source, this is the movement of dissolution of ego, letting go, surrendering, releasing all desires, allowing what is to be as it is, perfection in present, end of separation, less and less. Aligning yourself with this return movement you will use Mr Tolle's Teachings.

If you have unfulfilled desires, then LOA will appeal to you. If you have experienced enough, laughed enough, cried enough, suffered enough, and have began to see that all desires and manifestation will ultimately lead to suffering, only then you will resonate deeply with the teachings of Mr Tolle.


answered 05 Jan '12, 11:37

DesirelessAbundance's gravatar image



This appears to be a self-limiting viewpoint. Is there really an outgoing movement away from source? Isn't every external, illusional, manifestation contained within the One source of which we're all a part? Integration, not dissolution of the ego leads to the end of pain and suffering, because one has seen through attachment. Surely, if one has experienced, laughed and cried enough, then one has now, obviously, decided to exit this life experience and one is now dead. Consider that friend.

(23 Jan '12, 21:03) Eddie

Yes, Eddie, both the outward and inward movements happen within and through the one source. Both are necessary and complement each other for one cannot move in unless one has moved out.

The question here is are they compatible, and my answer is no for one cannot do both at the same time. Either you create or you surrender.

(30 Jan '12, 14:18) DesirelessAbundance

Eddie, Integration of ego sounds good, but still illusion. Dissolution is the only way to end the illusion. End of illusion means end of separation. One has to die to the false to live in truth. Ultimately separate existence itself is suffering. Liberation is not only from pain and suffering, but also from the experience of happiness as a separate entity, consider this also my friend.

(30 Jan '12, 14:19) DesirelessAbundance

@DesirelessAbundance - the law of attraction can be likened to a bar magnet with negative and positive poles ... the midpoint corresponds to the power of now, the pure power of creation :)

(30 Jan '12, 23:35) blubird two

@blubird two Never thought of it like that - might be good if you expanded it into a full answer.

(10 Aug '14, 04:16) Catherine
showing 2 of 5 show 3 more comments

Becoming conscious of Presence, being fully present in the Now stills the mind. Of course, thought is needed in a practical sense but it is not meant to tell us "who" we really are in Essence. So using thought in a positive and creative way is a good practical tool to create and manifest in the world of form. But we will never "think" our way to direct realization of Presence, Here and Now. In a practical sense, when we are entrapped in negative thoughts and feelings, learning how to pivot and consciously choose a better feeling thought is one of the tools that we we are given in the Law of Attraction teachings. My husband and I are deeply grateful for the tools like pivoting, segment intending etc. which have really made our outer experience one of our choosing rather than stumbling around in negativity and getting stuck there. Being conscious of Presence in this moment, right Now, several times throughout the day brings an awareness in the background even while we are dealing on a practical level. So we can use thought to play and create while being deeply Conscious of Presence - before, behind, and beyond any thought form that arises in the mind.

Everything is Nothing appearing as something... Being Conscious of Stillness, there is no identification with form, rather there is a deepening of Presence and the Conscious Awareness that is the Essence of every form.


answered 23 Jan '12, 16:41

AuntyHoney's gravatar image


What Eckhart is trying to say is "Contentment + Godliness = Great Gain". Contentment means being at peace with what is. Godliness is keeping our creative (: imaginative :) focus on our end result. Also, he's about one-ness i.e. we forget the illusion of separation and cease judging and realize that all is a reflection of what is inside us. Eckhart would call this "watching the movie about ourselves" and when we pay attention to now we know what we are because that is what we see reflected back to us and then we do have the option (: Eckhart does acknowledge co-creation :) to alter the inner state to see the automatic change in the outer. You may also opt for the end result of leading a purely detached life akin to a monk and that's fine too. There are many approaches but in the end: as you imagine within, so you experience without.


answered 05 Aug '14, 12:27

harsha's gravatar image


edited 05 Aug '14, 12:29

Great question - I went though a very similar phase of not knowing which felt right for me and even got into a discussion about it on IQ. The conclusion I've come to is that it depends on what you are intending to create. No one else can say what you are intending to create. In a way then I agree with Desireless Abundance - one is about creating, manifesting, thinking positively (even if all you want to manifest is happiness) and the other is about receptivity, letting go of desires, not thinking. Personally I find much wisdom in Eckhart Tolle's teachings (particularly being in the now moment) but I don't quite feel ready to really follow it wholeheartedly. Abraham's teachings have given me many great techniques for manifesting not just physical things but happiness, joy etc and I feel more empowered as a result but sometimes I find it lacks something that I can't articulate.

I know this is a vague answer but unless you are sure within yourself (when you wrote this answer you certainly weren't) I don't think there is a "right" answer for you. If others are sure, then it is because they have found their right way. Find your own right way and dip into many teachings for the time being. This may lead to confusion in the short term but once you've bombarded yourself with many different opinions you reach a point where you know that you can only trust your own inner guidance to tell you what is right for you at this moment.


answered 06 Aug '14, 04:21

Catherine's gravatar image


edited 06 Aug '14, 04:22

Eckhart Tolle has addressed these very questions, it's just not the main focus of his teaching.

According to Mr. Tolle, the "secret of the Universe" is "to no longer resist what is" and to find "an inner alignment with the form that this moment takes." "Miraculous things can happen...but they don't happen when you are out of alignment with what is; they only happen when you live in alignment with what is."

His complete answer is available in this very worthwhile, twelve-minute online video:


Sound familiar? :)

He also directly addressed the question of the Law of Attraction in a print interview, excerpted here:

Q: What is the fundamental difference between your teaching of presence and the current popular teaching called The Law of Attraction?

A: ...There are two means by which manifestation comes about. One is the ego's neediness to manifest, and another is out of the fullness of Presence, you can manifest. Even coming from the fullness of Presence, Presence can use also the human mind. Presence can flow through the mind and can energize your thoughts, and they are no longer dysfunctional. Whatever Presence wants to manifest through you, it can use the power of thought to manifest. It will come from a giving, there is a desire to give, not to get. Thought can be used and can be used more powerfully when the ego is no longer interfering.

When the human becomes co-creator with God, then Presence can flow into the human mind and use also human thought and create original things, and that's a beautiful thing. From Presence you do not create because you want whatever you create to satisfy you - because you are creating out of the satisfaction, out of Presence. The reason for creating then, is the joy of the act of creation. In the ego you do not have that, it's not the joy of the creation, it's the stress of the creation. You may get moments of joy, when momentarily the ego subsides, but then it comes back in again...

There are two movements in the Universe, it wants to create but it also wants to know itself. God, let's use the word... God obviously delights in creation. Look out into the Universe, at the infinite abundance of suns and galaxies and so on, billions and billions, the infinite abundance of creation on this planet, the complexity of life forms. Obviously God delights in the act of creation, and the dance of form. As we are here, we are part of that, we are form also. We can also delight in the world of form, either by creating new forms, or if we are frequency-holders or contemplatives, we can delight in the world of form by witnessing all the beauty that is already here around us, and bringing this light of consciousness into the world of forms that are already here. There are two ways you can delight in the world of form, as a co-creator and give birth to new forms, whatever it may be. You can also, even at the same time, be the witness of the incredible multiplicity of life forms that are continuously around you, and look in amazement at the miracle that surrounds you no matter where you are.

The whole of the above discussion can be read on Mr. Tolle's website:



answered 10 Aug '14, 20:05

lozenge123's gravatar image


Yeah, that's absolutely right based on my experience for the past 10 years and what a lot of past "masters" said + the essence of the Abraham-Hicks philosophy. It is also coded in the Bible as "contentment with Godliness (: using creative focus :) is great gain" and obviously contentment is non-resistance. I would clarify further that "finding alignment with what is" basically amounts to finding a way to feel as good as one can in the now.

(11 Aug '14, 06:57) harsha

@harsha - Thanks!

(11 Aug '14, 11:54) lozenge123

LOA and Eckhart Tolle (or any other non-dualist guru) are absolutely incompatible.

All spiritual teachers, ET included, maintain that desire comes from the ego, and desire and ego should be banished.

LOA is alll about fulfilment of desire.

You can draw your own conclusion from this.

As far as I am concerned, I am very happy being an egoic person full of desires, and I have no interest whatsoever in what spiritual teachers like ET have to say.

Eckhart Tolle's teaching in particular is so full of holes that the less talked about it the better.


answered 19 Aug '14, 15:44

cod2's gravatar image


edited 19 Aug '14, 15:45

@cod2 - I was a little perplexed by your answer, which seems to contradict the very essence of what Eckhart Tolle himself explains in the video interview that I posted above. Namely, the statement that "All spiritual teachers, ET included, maintain that desire comes from the ego, and desire and ego should be banished". Just to be sure, I flipped through my copy of The Power of Now to see if I could find such a statement from Eckhart Tolle...

(19 Aug '14, 16:05) lozenge123

...What I found was: "Don't seek to become free of desire or 'achieve' enlightenment. Become present. Be there as the observer of the mind." (The Power of Now, Eckhart Tolle, p. 25) So he is not saying that you should (or even can) banish desire, but rather, not to seek "salvation" in the fulfillment of desires. This is completely consistent with the LOA teachings of Bashar, Abraham, and many others. Once again: http://www.lawofattractiontv.net/eckhart-tolle-the-secret-of-the-universe/ :)

(19 Aug '14, 16:06) lozenge123

Nope. They are exactly the same except that non-duality is less about chasing specific goals and even that is not too different because Abraham-Hicks often say "Go General" and learn to make peace with where you are. However, if you are always displeased with what is (: which is really a manifestation of your state of mind :) then you just recall or imagine something that makes you feel better (: a memory recalled or future imagined is always in the now :).

(19 Aug '14, 17:02) harsha

Only one thing that is really important is different: Abraham-Hicks is focused on continued creative evolution (: which is also a good thing if one prefers it :) whereas a lot of non duality teachers focus on attaining Oneness with "All" and staying there permanently. Still others would prefer to experience other realms. That's probably the only real difference. Although LOA focuses on materialism a lot, it is required that spiritual well-being is first sought after and valued.

(19 Aug '14, 17:09) harsha
showing 2 of 4 show 2 more comments

I won't give my opinion. Here is Abraham Hick's own words talking about "The Now" and how it is important, just as Eckhart Tolle does:

"Tomorrow never comes. Have you noticed? 'cause when it gets here it's today! All of your power is NOW" 2:56 - 3:05



answered 20 Aug '14, 16:14

arpgme's gravatar image


Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website



Asked: 29 Jun '10, 07:43

Seen: 5,395 times

Last updated: 20 Aug '14, 16:14

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here



Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Related Questions