If i go to sleep and dream am I astral traveling?

asked 03 Nov '09, 08:11

flowingwater's gravatar image


edited 11 Aug '10, 16:46

Barry%20Allen's gravatar image

Barry Allen ♦♦

From what I've read and from my own (limited) experience the dream world and the astral world seem to be two very close yet distinct plains or layers of reality. A lot of people maintain that "lucid dreaming" and astral projection are the same thing but I don't think so. You can astral project directly from the physical body but you can also do it in a dream. The latter is much easier but first you have to become "lucid" or conscious inside a dream.

So my answer is no, dreams are not necessarily astral travel, even though the experience of both can be very similar.
What follows is a personal experience if anyone cares to read it:

A few years ago I was actively practicing lucid dreaming and I was having some success. One night I had a normal dream of being in some kind of library. At some point I realized this must be a dream and started to explore it but then something unexpected happened. I can't be absolutely sure about this but I think that my astral body started separating from my dream body. I became frightened at first and tried to stop the process but eventually I pulled myself together and reminded myself that nothing can hurt me here. I encouraged the separation and pretty soon I (in my astral body) was facing my "dream" body, which become unconscious so I had to support it and put it gently on the ground. It was actually kinda funny. :)
In an instant the setting changed. I was in my parents home, everything was very clear and vivid, much more so then before "separating". The experience didn't last very long and soon I returned to my physical body.

I think in the above story I went from the dream world to the astral plane but I don't have enough experience to be absolutely sure about it.


answered 03 Nov '09, 09:12

Toshiro's gravatar image


edited 03 Nov '09, 14:20

thankyou for sharing your story. Late reply, but that's really cool to hear

(07 Sep '11, 14:56) Nikulas

I have to disagree witj Rani Oberoi. As far as I'm concerned your imagination and your dreams are maybe even more real then physical reality. Why do I think that? Because I believe that we are spiritual beings having a human experience, not the other way around.

Supposebly in the moment of dying you enter into a domain in which your physical experience, your physical life seems pretty much as a dream. You can remember it but vaguely and soon you are in touch with your true nature, as a being vast as the cosmos.

Dreams are real because their are the way of our Higher Self to communicate with our physical Mind. Their's a lot of symbolisim in your dreams becauser that's the way Higher Mind can communicate. Otherwise physical mind can not comprehend the realizations made by our Higher Self.

So are dreams real? I believe they are but everybody has to make their own distinctions. I have had lucid dreaming in the past and the feeling of exiliration and freedom when you know you can do anything you want without social pressure is undiscrebable. But is this real? After I woke up I always had the feeling of peace and harmony with me, so the emotion was real. Does anything else count?

In regard to your question I personally don't see the distinction significant. I feel we can split uor perception into to poralities: The known and the unknown. The known is everything you have a name for, everything that has been ever said, felt, experienced etc. Unknown is everything else. Right now as a species we are tapping into the unknown, but more important than give them labels I feel that what we experience is much more real and much more undisturbed this way. Just like I'm just not able to put into words the times when I was lucid dreaming, smoked salvia, had multiple orgasm or 4 hand massage. They were all experiences one of a kind and words just distort what I got out of them. But I'm also a book-worm which means I want to understand too, but for hundred hours of reading one hour of doing is that much more valuable :-)


answered 03 Nov '09, 15:27

wildlife's gravatar image


We all have our own opinions I suppose.

(03 Nov '09, 17:29) Pink Diamond

Sure we do, that's what makes life exciting :-)

(06 Nov '09, 14:03) wildlife

@wildlife - what if the spiritual and physical are interdependent, then both realms are just as real as each other ... ?

(29 Feb '12, 00:32) blubird two
showing 2 of 3 show 1 more comments

Dreams are not real manifestations. You cannot create anything physically in your dreams. Everything is terms of manifestation happens when you are awake.

Dreams are just a manifestation of what you have been thinking during your awake state. However, once you are awake and think and talk about your dreams, these thoughts do affect your reality.

In answer to your question, you are not astral travelling in your dreams as dreams are not physical manifestations.


answered 03 Nov '09, 16:13

Pink%20Diamond's gravatar image

Pink Diamond

very late question- most young men think of girls all day, including me. Yet I don't seem to have dreams about them, perhaps once every 4 months or so. I'm not trying to test you or put you on the spot- just if you could explain that to me please I'd be most greatful :)

(07 Sep '11, 14:58) Nikulas

I actively astral-traveled in my sleep as a young child- it was very different than dreaming...they are two very different states. I have written before about this elsewhere on this site. I remember very clearly the morning the angels told me that I was no longer allowed to "leave" my body any more...It made me very sad, as the feeling was wonderful.

This is, or could be, a very philosophical question. The Buddhists ask, "Which is reality? Life, or the Dream? Or Life, and Death (The Void)? Which is real?"

But some people, like Wade, actively lucid dream...which I envy. He controls his dreams at will- I have had only a very few lucid dreams...I believe that this can be learned, but I also believe that these dreams are a special type of dream which (my own theory) combines the dream state with the astral plane in some new way. It would be very interesting to do an EEG of Wade while he is lucid dreaming- just to see if he is in an Alpha state, or Delta, or whatever...

The two planes are similar, and connected, but not the same at all. Dreaming is very different than being out-of-body on the astral plane.




answered 29 Feb '12, 02:43

Jaianniah's gravatar image


@Jai - very interesting ... according to Barbara Brennan the astral world is a fourth spatial dimension that co-exists with our linear time/space everyday world, here is an article


have fun

(29 Feb '12, 04:09) blubird two

@blubird two- I love Barbara Brennan- thanks for the link! I was reading her books way back when she first published them...I always wanted to go to her school...No $$$$$$....Blessings, Jai

(29 Feb '12, 11:34) Jaianniah
Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website



Asked: 03 Nov '09, 08:11

Seen: 1,362 times

Last updated: 29 Feb '12, 11:34

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here



Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Related Questions