Inward Quest has the lifelong, almost politcal, battle with this very large question-

Is action necessary in manifestation?

There is sufficient information already on the website to gain insights into this. My question is more specific, very quick, and that is, does anyone ever recall Abraham promoting the method of taking action? And please note, this question excludes any involvement to the 22 processes of raising your vibration. I'm talking about actual physical action necessary to get what you want.

Obviously, physical action usually naturally happens, but as far as the Abraham teachings go, all one has to do is feel good, and all desires are met. True?

Again, this question is targeted at Abraham teachings, not the general LOA metaphysics, where some promote action.

asked 21 Sep '11, 14:12

Nikulas's gravatar image


edited 21 Sep '11, 15:23

Barry%20Allen's gravatar image

Barry Allen ♦♦

Stingray has mentioned before somewhere that it isn't really necessary to take any action to manifest the things you want - literally you could just stay at home the whole day and yet still be able to manifest the things you want.. its just that humans are conditioned into thinking that they have to work in order to achieve the things they want and it is difficult for one to shrug this belief off if it is their first time trying to manifest something.. but I think Stingray will pop in to this thread anyway soon :)

(21 Sep '11, 16:33) kakaboo

Hmm... Good question begets good answers.

(23 Sep '11, 02:18) Vesuvius
showing 0 of 2 show 2 more comments

I agree with the good answers already here so there's little point me repeating them.

So I'll just throw in a few extra comments that might be useful to others reading this thread...

To my knowledge - from listening to Abraham since the mid-90s - Abraham have only once directly talked about action before alignment and that is the basic idea that Manifesting Experiment 3 is based upon - though I've made a few additional tweaks here and there to what they suggested to make it more goal-oriented.

I know you're not asking about action-based processes but I think, for the sake of completeness and understanding, it's important to contrast Abraham's approach directly with the alternative otherwise you might be missing out on the bigger picture.

Even though Abraham are not fans of an action-first approach, it does not mean that action-first is not a legitimate approach. Action-based goal-setting would never work if action-first did not work...but the trick to making it work is the intention you have behind doing the action.

Action-first is absolutely legitimate if you are taking action with the intention of bringing about alignment. And the main channeled advocate of this idea is Bashar.

Bashar simply states that you should do the most exciting thing you can right now for as long as you can, then do the next most exciting thing, then the next and the next.

Each most-exciting action brings you closer into alignment with your Vortex (Abraham's term, not Bashar's), which then inspires the next action, and the next, and the next...and so on.

So which approach should you use? ...alignment-first or action-first?

I think it really depends on your belief system regarding the subject you are focused on.

I find that if I don't really feel like doing anything towards a goal I have, or I don't know what to do next, or I just don't know how to do what I want to do then that's a clear indication that alignment-first is required...effectively through the Manifesting Experiment 1 - Manifesting Box idea (you can do this in your head also without requiring a written request) or through any of Abraham's vibrational techniques.

On the other hand, if I am absolutely clear, inspired and excited about what to do next, I don't force myself to sit around and do nothing - I just do it :) ...and when the excitement dissipates, I'll either work on Vortex alignment or I'll just do something else that feels "exciting".

I'll never really plan that far ahead though because I won't know what the next best inspiring thing to do is until I reach the next vibrational place. So I'm constantly asking myself if I feel inspired to do something (if I'm in a good-feeling place) or whether it's time to just find ways to feel better (see Vortex First, Any Way You Can, Then Everything Else)

Remember that it's never about getting things done - because you'll never get your life "done" - it's about catching up with that ever-expanding state of alignment (The Vortex) so if taking an action is what achieves that for you then taking that action is just as valid an approach as deliberate vibrational molding of thought.

Abraham have said that action was always intended to be a way of plucking the fruits of our vibrational alignment rather than as a way of physically forcing manifestations into place.


answered 22 Sep '11, 10:32

Stingray's gravatar image


Re your paragraph about Manifesting Box Method- I do the exact same thing. When I just know what I want but I do not know where to start or I feel like doing nothing about it, I do this method. And it has worked wonders in my life. I am just too tired to share the manifestations in the thread about it. Sometimes, if I know where to start or what to do, I still do it, stay still, and wait for the promptings of the Universe on what I must do, and that is the only time I take action. It is still my most favorite manifesting method Stingray. It's just like ordering from a restaurant. So simple.

(22 Sep '11, 16:36) Aphrodite

Yes, it's almost too simple and I think that's why many people don't even try it. There seems to be an underlying belief with many that life must be complicated to understand, or there must be some great hidden secret somewhere, or there must be some mysterious set of rules and rituals to follow. And yet, it all falls into place when one can accept the idea of simply asking for what you want (anything you want) and just letting it come to you without any guilt, need, morality or any self-justification at all. It just comes because you asked for it. That's all :)

(22 Sep '11, 18:05) Stingray

How do I edit to my comment? I was supposed to say Sometimes, EVEN IF I KNOW WHAT TO DO, I still do the Box Method and wait for the promptings of the Universe. Oh well, you get the point. Simplify, simplify, simplify - Thoreau

(23 Sep '11, 02:27) Aphrodite
showing 2 of 3 show 1 more comments

Abraham always advises to follow inspired action. It wouldn't feel like a burden to you or you would just naturally do it without really thinking about it. Abraham doesn't want you to go out looking for a relationship if you're still not in a good vibrational place from your last relationship. There was an example in the book Law of Attraction, where a woman was getting over a negative relationship but immediately headed out to meet someone new, without trying to work with her vibrations before doing so. She attracted another negative, abusive relationship in doing so.

As long as you work with your vibrations, situations will be presented to you and unfold perfectly for you. Action will be just as easy as sailing down the river. This is why Abraham focuses so much more on talking about your vibrations rather than the action you must take, because as long as you're in the right vibrational place action will not be an issue for you.

I manifested a car this way. I didn't think about the money or how to get it. I didn't even look up cars online or talk to anyone. I just wanted a car, a blue or black car.

A few months later, a friend ended up receving a free car. It was damaged and the original owner didn't want to deal with and just bought a new car. He fixed it and ended up selling it to me; i only had to pay for what it took to repair it, so I ended up with a 3,000 dollar discount, more or less. Also, it was dark blue, which I found a little funny :) And I just have to say, I am so in love with my car... best car I've ever had.

Just stay in vibrational alignment with what you want, and let the universe unfold the ways you'll receive it... This is what I've always interpreted Abraham's teachings in a nutshell to be.


answered 21 Sep '11, 15:41

LapisLazuli's gravatar image


I like this answer.

(22 Sep '11, 07:23) Paulina 1

It's funny you brought this question up because I am currently ready Money and the Law of Attraction for the first time and one of my recent notes I jotted down sums up action pretty well I think.

Financial success, or any other kind of success, does not require hard work or action, but it does require alignment of thought. You simply cannot offer negative thought about things that you desire and then make up for it with action or hard work. When you learn to direct your own thoughts, you will discover true energy alignment.

Personally, I don't ever recall Abraham promoting just action without thought first. I'm not saying that it was never said since there is so much material out there but everything that I have been learning is along the lines of inspired action.

I have been down the road many times in the past with just plain ole action before and I have learned that it usually leads to not so great places. Especially when it's reactive action like when someone is trying to push your buttons. Taking the time to pause and think a circumstance or situation out first, lining up with that good feeling place, and then letting your inspiration lead you down the right path is the only thing Abraham has taught me. When you come from a place in your life of instantly reacting to people and situations in your life like I did for a long long time, inspired action seems so much more downstream and peaceful it isn't even funny.

Abraham is a teacher that pounds your thoughts and feelings are the only thing that matters so much into their material that it is truly hard for me to think of a time when just action alone has been mentioned.


answered 21 Sep '11, 20:49

Cory's gravatar image


Hey Nikulas,

I will try and explain the way I see things, and hopefully you will see the logic in it and understand the idea.

The action itself, unless inspired (which is always mentally effortless), is useless. What matters is what you believe the action will cause.

For example, finding a new job. If one believes he must search in sites that offer jobs in the internet, and set his resume to many employees, and go to job interviews - then he holds the belief "in order to get a job, I have to search for positions, send my resume and go through an interview". After he takes those actions and gets the job, he thinks that his actions caused it - but it is not true. Only after he took action, he ALLOWED himself to align with the idea of getting a new job. Only after taking the action, could his belief system ALLOW the change in belief to happen. So really the action did nothing. It was just his limiting belief that the action was ever required, that cuased him to resist getting a job without taking action.

If he believed he could manifest a new position without any action, then that's what he would exactly get. Reality conforms to our beliefs.

However any physical action that helps you change your beliefs, such as Stingray's Manifesting Experiment 3, is very helpful because you are "tricking" your belief system (if you are very action oriented) to offer less resistance to the idea that "I must take action".

Lester Levenson said once that the highest level of action available is the action of releasing (resistance). Or like Charles Hannel wrote in the "Master Key System" - "To change the effect, you must change the cause". The cause is your thoughts and beliefs. The effect is actions and results.

I'm sorry if I went a bit off-topic with this post but I think this explains a part of the intention of teachers like Abraham.


answered 22 Sep '11, 12:49

Benjamin's gravatar image


There was a time that I manifested a new car with no action on my part and I wrote about that someplace here on IQ. I think if the timing is right and you are very adept it is certainly possible. But truthfully I have manifested much more by taking correct action at key times. Much more.


answered 21 Sep '11, 20:56

LeeAnn%201's gravatar image

LeeAnn 1

Good for you LeeAnn.

(22 Sep '11, 07:26) Paulina 1

Bravo LeeAnn. More to go!

(22 Sep '11, 16:37) Aphrodite

The first time I think I've ever answered my question, so here it goes.

Listening to Ask and It is Given Part 2, one of the methods used that really stood out (in relation to my question) was process number 20 - "turning it over to the manager." I've listened to this one about 5 times now.

Everyone can agree you don't want this universe to do everything. For a small example, you don't want the universe to lick your ice-cream for you- you'd like to do that yourself. That is what action is- it is actually a really fun, exciting and "delicious" part of the manifestation process. It is (exagerated) now where you drive the car, where you go on the date, where you spend your lottery fortunes. Being more realistic (and the word realistic is actually a bit humurous, isn't it?), action may just be buying the lotto ticket.

But also to add in with Stingrays information, whereas one may need to do action to produce the vibration...Whatever work, I quote from Joe Vitale in a golden piece of advice from the Secret

"Remember, the universe likes SPEED." And action, dependable on people's beliefs, is an element of getting faster and faster.

Everyone's answers here helped me a lot, everyone pretty much got it spot-on on the nail. Thankyou so much again Inward Quest, LeeAnn, Stingray, Benjamin, Cory, Lazuli :)


answered 22 Sep '11, 23:44

Nikulas's gravatar image


Ah, turning it over to the manager... Effortless!

(23 Sep '11, 02:24) Aphrodite

"you don't want the universe to lick your ice-cream for you- you'd like to do that yourself." I love that ! Hehe :)

(23 Sep '11, 13:12) LapisLazuli
Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website



Asked: 21 Sep '11, 14:12

Seen: 2,188 times

Last updated: 22 Sep '11, 23:44

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here



Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text]( "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Related Questions