The universal law of attraction states: like attracts like. So why is an electron always repelled by another electron?

asked 09 Oct '09, 08:21

ali's gravatar image

ali
8112

edited 09 Oct '09, 08:59

Barry%20Allen's gravatar image

Barry Allen ♦♦
11411

nice, thanks....

(22 Nov '10, 17:39) Back2Basics

Great question.

(14 Apr '12, 05:13) Paulina 1
showing 0 of 2 show 2 more comments

13

I have to explain this is a with music as music is a form of vibration we can all relate to.

If I have a piano in one room and I play a note on a violin in another room, this same note will resonate so much that this same note if you are sitting near the piano you will hear coming from the piano. This is a Law Sympathetic Resonance, a little less esoteric than Law of Attraction, however really the Law of Attraction is really the Law of Sympathetic Resonance at much higher frequencies of thought.

It s not the same as electrons, energy or magnets it is more like music actually our whole universe is like a big symphony of music, this is why the law of attraction works for like attracts like.

We are trying to compare two different things, in each world there are different laws, for example we say water always seeks it's level that is a law, but if we go down to a bug eye view, no the law is wrong, water is round and sticks up like a bubble it has a surface that is bulbous.

That is because a drop of water has more resistance to gravity than say a bucket of water, because the drop is too small for gravity to push flat so instead it does as best as it can and pushes down all around and that forms the drop.

link

answered 06 Jan '10, 06:04

Wade%20Casaldi's gravatar image

Wade Casaldi
34.6k11156

1

Nice answer. +1

(06 Jan '10, 06:09) Vesuvius
1

Yes my years of study in my mystery school came through on this one! :-D Thanks

(06 Jan '10, 06:18) Wade Casaldi
1

I believe I actually learned this through the book The Secret Doctrine of the Rosicrucians which has now been made public domain, I have the original book hard cover http://www.sacred-texts.com/sro/sdr/index.htm

(06 Jan '10, 06:24) Wade Casaldi
1

Wow, Wade Casaldi that was deep. So, you learn this in mystery school. All answers depends on the view you are looking at and the point from which you are standing viewing it.

(11 Jan '10, 07:18) flowingwater
1

Yes very good! :D

(11 Jan '10, 07:45) Wade Casaldi
1

Loved this answer. When it comes to LOA harmony rules.

(14 Apr '12, 05:18) Paulina 1
showing 3 of 6 show 3 more comments



I used to ponder a similar question. In my case it was magnets, I believe, since teachers often use the magnet-metaphor to explain the LoA. Why does like attract like if magnets are always attracted by the opposite pole? I didn't find a satisfying, scientific answer but here is my practical solution: LoA on one hand and electrons/magnets or whatever physical thing we like to compare it with on the other, simply do not work the same way. They function on completely different levels and are governed by different forces.

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 09:40

Toshiro's gravatar image

Toshiro
1.8k48

However, all scientific explanation of the LOA revolves around the magnetic spectrum and other such experiments. i.e. - Our thought can be detected on a electric detector.

(22 Nov '10, 17:45) Back2Basics

Read Wades answer.

(14 Apr '12, 05:23) Paulina 1

Here's the way I understand it. The thoughts you have are positive in polarity and the material manifestation or condition is negative in polarity. The polarity of your thoughts attract the opposite polarity of the material conditions. Therefore, bad thoughts attract bad conditions, and good thoughts attract good conditions. In other words, like attracts like. OR, you could say bad thoughts repel good conditions and good thoughts repel bad conditions.

I think Melchizedek1 says it best that everything is vibrational in nature. Like a tuning fork will resonate with those tones that are in harmony with it. So with our thoughts resonating with those conditions that are in harmony with them. Again, like attracts like. It is only a matter of rates of vibration to determine the polarity of a vibration. Thoughts being a rate of positive polarity and material conditions being a harmonious rate of negative polarity. Therefore our thoughts resonating or attracting those things or conditions that are in harmony with them.

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 09:48

RPuls's gravatar image

RPuls
5.0k1724

edited 11 Oct '09, 08:50

"The thoughts you have are positive in polarity and the material manifestation or condition is negative in polarity." - Who says? how do we know this is true?

(22 Nov '10, 17:43) Back2Basics

I like your answer.

(14 Apr '12, 05:26) Paulina 1

In addition to the above explanation in reference to this question,If I may say that the type of attraction they are referring to is not of Magnetic attraction but of visualization process at a vibrationary level of the focal immage of the mental mind. This is akin to the inverse reflection of images to produce same image as in the refraction Law of physics.So, what this translate metaphysically speaking is to visualize positive result wherby such manifestation wiyll bring about such manifested poaitive result.

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 10:59

Melchizedek1's gravatar image

Melchizedek1
772

Many explanations of the Law of Attraction use particle physics to validate the scientific basis for the Law of Attraction. Therefore, one cannot use particles on one hand to validate the Law of Attraction and then on the other hand say that one is comparing apples to oranges.

I think perhaps, we must realize that the Law of Attraction is only one Universal Law that works in tandem with other Universal Laws. In addition, we must realize that we don't yet understand all the specifics of the way that spiritual consciousness creates the physical universe nor how our individual intentions interact. We often forget that we are all in this together. Every consciousness for itself has never ended well.

Vibrational resonance can change the orbit of planets. Magnetism does not operate alone, the force is actually electromagnetism. Gravity or more accurately space-time continuum is warped and affected by mass - and what is mass? Concentration of energy. Perhaps the Law of Attraction is really a form of gravity.

In addition, thought is not the most important component in Attraction. It is our Being. Our thoughts and emotions often spring from our Being, but they are not the source of our true power. Our desires are the carrot that can motivate us to change who we are Being.

But just ignoring our negative thoughts and emotions by covering them over with positive platitudes will not attract the changes we seek. It only serves to increase our dishonesty and put more distance between us and our true spirit. Feelings are the language of the Soul. We would do well to listen to the message instead of discounting a feeling that we deem as negative. If it guides us to the solution to expand our Being, is it really negative after all?

link

answered 10 Jan '10, 05:26

user-461%20%28google%29's gravatar image

user-461 (google)
6111

Wow love this answer. Very wise.

(14 Apr '12, 05:32) Paulina 1

You are not comparing apples to apples. The electron attraction and repelling is dealing with magnetism. The law of attraction is with the laws of resonance. Two totally different aspects of physics.

link

answered 10 Oct '09, 22:11

I%20Believe's gravatar image

I Believe
1912

Well, not exactly. Electrons are repelled from each other by an electric charge. Although electrons do generate a miniscule magnetic field, it is not this field that repels other electrons. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron#Interaction

(13 Oct '09, 04:25) Vesuvius

I'm somehow finding the opposite to be true, that opposites DO attract. Here is my musical example: If you play two notes at the exact same loudness and tone then they will cancel each other out and you will not be able to hear them. Other examples: Good doesn't exist without evil, you don't exist without me, God told Adam not to eat the apple, yin and yang, and how could you read this black text if the background was black too? Also, has anyone noticed how when you talk about love you always find haters and on days you hate the world your always shown love? I'm not saying to start hating, I'm just saying that's what you'll attract, besides all those haters will just attract more love from you. I've had experiences with successful LOA but the success came at times were I wasn't trying to attract at all. I just had a lack that I knew I had and the universe filled it in. When I consciously try to attract things I really do feel like I'm repelling the universe. You want more proof: This post is going to attract some opposite reactions. The previous sentence was a paradox because you're going to have to agree to disagree.

I'm not trying to wreck anyone's beliefs or anything. This is just my opinion trying to shed some understanding as I try to understand myself. :)

-peace

link

answered 13 Jul '11, 23:17

Plebis%20Mentis's gravatar image

Plebis Mentis
5111

edited 15 Jul '11, 17:08

Wade%20Casaldi's gravatar image

Wade Casaldi
34.6k11156

OK I thought about an answer for myself because something wasn't quite resonating and I didn't want to have to make someone feel wrong in dealing with my paradox anyways... My conclusion is that opposites do attract BUT they must be similar to do so. Like how the north pole of a magnet doesn't attract a woman. How the color black doesn't repel a musical note. However, two magnets stacked together make a stronger magnet. With LOA, I can now see how thoughts would resonate with reality but through positive manifestation, its easy to attract negative thoughts that can throw you off. So, its both.

(14 Jul '11, 22:19) Plebis Mentis
1

Some truth in your answer...however, I don't necessarily think we have to "agree to disagree", there is always 'compromise' or finding 'the middle way' :)

(15 Jul '11, 01:32) Michaela

@Michaela. I like your reply. I'm finally on that level where I'm beginning to see 'the middle way.' A lot of people like to take sides (I know I used to) but why wouldn't an infinite universe compensate for multiple truths. Thanks

(16 Jul '11, 10:17) Plebis Mentis

this is such a good question, i have always told myself that the law of attraction is based more on your sustained thoughts and not on physics!

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 13:36

eziospags's gravatar image

eziospags
1211

Like attracts like and opposites attract each other. that's the complete law of attraction. for example : if you are thinking about wealth, your actions and your thoughts would reflect what you are thinking about, that is wealth. but, does that mean if you are thinking about weatlh you will become wealthy? .. no. you may lose all money you have! .. but you still got a reaction about the same subject. wealth. like attracts like. to the second part of the law, opposites attract each other : we desire something when we don't have it. for example, we desire health when we are sick. it's in your mind ( positive ) but it's not in your experience ( negative ). that's when opposites attract each other.

link

answered 10 Oct '09, 21:32

Adel's gravatar image

Adel
1.8k48

nice observation.....

(22 Nov '10, 17:50) Back2Basics

Electrons exist in the physical plane, not the mental plane.

link

answered 10 Jan '10, 17:42

Timothy%20Haggerty's gravatar image

Timothy Haggerty
311

I not sure but I think + poles of magnets repel. I also heard in romance opposites attract. in other words the rocks in your head fit the holes in hers hehe. Think of it in a Karmic way. You reap what you sow. Put out positive and receive positive.

link

answered 19 Nov '10, 01:45

Tom's gravatar image

Tom
4.8k217

yes I am aware of magnetic poles and the saying in romance. However, I have to say that most of the LOA things I read mention LIKE things attract....so I get confused! o well, thanks

(19 Nov '10, 02:22) Back2Basics
1

Back2Basics your answer is in your question-they are talking about the mental world not the physical world. In Mind like attracts like. The seed or thought grows it own kind. You may think love and attract hate at first but hold the thought and love will come.

(19 Nov '10, 03:49) Tom

I thought the mental world is the energy world?

(22 Nov '10, 17:40) Back2Basics

Back2Basics, It looks like you just want to disagree with me. OK ask Stingray.

(23 Nov '10, 23:06) Tom
showing 3 of 4 show 1 more comments

Harmonic Resonance is the answer. Same as Sympathetic Resonance. Nicola Tesla did extensive work in this field but because his findings did not "resonate" with the perceptions of Newtonian physicists his ideas were ignored. Today, we have the same problem with this question. LOA does not resonate well to those indoctrinated in the dogma of Newtonian physics. Galileo ran into a similar problem - if you recall.

One word of warning though - to those believing that thoughts are not "things" WRONG! Look at any modern up to date chart of electromagnetism and you will see that brain wave frequencies account for a very large amount of "stuff" on that chart. Every single thing consists of energy vibrating at specific frequencies. That's what e=MC2 means!

Truth is that this is at the very heart of this debate. Thoughts ARE "things". They have weight and mass. In the 50's and 60's the Russians built machines to record AND decipher thoughts. Successfully. This fact had far much more to do with the "Cold War" than most Americans can ever imagine.

Read "Psychic Discoveries" by Sheila Ostrander and Lynn Schroder and also "The Field" by Lynne McTaggart. All women I might note. These are science researchers talking to leading edge scientists. NOT philosophers as the Newtonians would have you believe. Stretch yourself - read this stuff. It is PROOF.

OUR life depends on it.

link

answered 13 Apr '12, 23:59

jogjr's gravatar image

jogjr
812

Well done, I love your answer and have read those books. Fascinating and true.

(14 Apr '12, 05:58) Paulina 1

i agree on tesla finding he took nature as example. to bad that they did not agree for free power for every one and cut is founding and destroy is lab. again the little darkness was responsible.

(14 Apr '12, 06:09) white tiger

like attracts like. Because the negetive is always in competition with the positive. But they both from the same power, and they understand each other

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 08:45

Nii's gravatar image

Nii
311

dont be logical in questioning....s...its true that like attracts like...then y does a man attract a woman????r they alike??? its the passion or deep desire to become united and transform themselves to a higher consciousness...is the likeness between them that makes them feel attracted to each other....the same way are the protons or electrons or etc... the thing just happened a few millenniums back...was that a few people who observed the reluctance shown by the protons / electrons made use of his observation ...named it as repulsion and used it for a better mankind... There after every one followed it blindly as it was found something newly beneficial...

LIFE IS JUST A WOMB OF ULTIMATE COMMON SENSE....

link

answered 09 Oct '09, 12:55

Haripriya's gravatar image

Haripriya
211

I think of your question in terms of a magnet that will attract everything, and anything that it come into contact with, but is limited to things that it does not comes into contact with. So in terms of life experiences, although we may attract something thing, it may not in fact, be good for us, or we may at first think so, but on second thought finds it repulsive, and would disregard it totally. So although we have made the initial contact to bond, perhaps there would be no bonding in the future!

link

answered 24 Nov '10, 03:05

Inactive%20User's gravatar image

Inactive User ♦♦
5721171

in magnetism or electricity similar repel and opposite attract, like male and female. magnetism is alignement of electron in the same way. and when you move magnet near a wire you produce electricity electron moving in the same direction(i would say that it makes a cooperation from the electron from the magnet to cooperate with the electron in the wire and give them the same alignement in the same direction). magnetism and electricity can be convert one to the other. from magnet you can produce electricity and from electricity you can produce electro-magnet. law are more then dead stone. try to produce a child from a male to a male or a female to a female. you know that nature does not work that way.but you can make a child from a male to a female. so if they teach that like attract like i would say that is not the law of attraction but the law of repulsion. the law of attraction would be a cooperation of similar align element in the same way. yet those 2 law can work together they are use in electro-magnetism. so basically it is how you applie those law in unity with your free will that makes the appropriate result.

link

answered 14 Apr '12, 01:01

white%20tiger's gravatar image

white tiger
19.5k1742

edited 14 Apr '12, 01:17

Click here to create a free account

Tags:

×805
×142

Asked: 09 Oct '09, 08:21

Seen: 4,065 times

Last updated: 14 Apr '12, 06:09

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported



Related Questions