Do we just make up a spiritual explanation of mundane and/or inner psychological experience, rationalizing away any evidence that contradicts it for the sake of hiding from our awareness of life's finitude and our lack of control? Is spirituality merely a delusion? Please justify your answer. It is my hope that someone will help convince me that the answer is no.

asked 20 Jan '13, 17:39

flowsurfer's gravatar image


Life itself is irrational. And few are able to understand contradicting nature of it. Most are afraid to understand, thus they side with rational ideas and philosophies. Like recognizing only side of existential terror.

(21 Jan '13, 01:44) CalonLan

@calonlan if i told you that life is very rationnal and that only because people are not aware and do not know that they find it very irrationnal. they are only at the very first step of their journey.and that is why it gives the experience that you are having right now. should you fear and be terrorize?

(21 Jan '13, 02:26) white tiger

@white tiger, the only rational thing about life is its irrationality. But I spoke of rationality with which people side, as opposed to irrationality from which they run away, which in fact is just as rational as the other rational part they side with. But it is these two rational parts opposing each other that create irrationality people fear. Although as said, it's this irrationality of life that's perfectly rational.

(21 Jan '13, 03:45) CalonLan

flowsurfer, it is just the other way around, the truth is and our task to see and hear it with clarity

(21 Jan '13, 06:45) fred

@fred, task? Are you suggesting a meaning of life. lol

(21 Jan '13, 06:49) CalonLan

calonlan, yes, Infinite Mind does not roll dice, yet It weeps, at times, for what It sees His creative force has opted to do

(21 Jan '13, 16:15) fred
showing 1 of 6 show 5 more comments

The phrase "Love and Light" is often seen here. Change your interpretation of spirituality to love. When you know love you know spirituality. The Idea of God as separate from you is a misconception (God,Source, the universe). If you think of your soul/spirit as a line extending from horizon to horizon that you see neither beginning nor end of. and this physical phase of this line is just a dot of light along it. Preceded and followed by a multitude of dots of light. Then think of countless strands of theses crossing each other running parallel to each other.@Jaiannia describes it well in this question there is no existential terror as such this terror you describe comes from within ones own-self.Negative beliefs and preconceptions .Take the "God" out of the clouds looking down and judging you to a "God" that fills and radiates from within you Love and Light!


answered 21 Jan '13, 04:03

ursixx's gravatar image


What is love?

Consider this question. How does God know he is God?

(21 Jan '13, 10:04) flowsurfer

@flowsurfer how do you know that you are you?well it is the same for God.what did God say to moses when he asked is name. i am who i am,i am that i am. God is aware of himself and know himself. like all of you made in is image should be aware and know your self.

(21 Jan '13, 16:41) white tiger

1st a chair dance sorry just needed a moment of disco silliness ....

(21 Jan '13, 17:09) ursixx

a few minutes ago I comment on something calonlan said in a comment with: "I had a brain storm, what if you consider love more than a emotion. It is an energy,a vibration.That we are born with.It,s like your heart beat. Always with you.Until you are no longer psychically here ,then it follows you into the eternal!?" as far as "god" is concerned I sure it/he/she has many identities and realizes all of them.

(21 Jan '13, 17:13) ursixx
showing 2 of 4 show 2 more comments

Perhaps...Just perhaps...somewhere deep inside a desire to feel The Spiritual of Life.

There have been many who have. Down through the ages, men and women have had inexplicable spiritual experiences which proved to them, at least, that there is a Spiritual World just Outside this one, and it weaves itself into our lives because we are not just physical, but spiritual, too.

When I was a small child, I left my body and flew! I did! I always wondered at this, until one dark day, I needed that memory. I had to remember because the experience proved to me that I have a Soul, separate from my body. It was not hallucination...I was too young for such nonsense. i was not stoned, drugged, insane, or intellectualizing. I was a small girl, just experiencing.

Those who experience God or the Spirit are called Mystics. They sense the Presence of Spirit, and have written many, many things about what they have seen and felt. I learned a saying long ago which helps me with this sometimes:

"If you cannot believe in a God of your own, Borrow Mine."

It works. I freely welcome you to try out my God!




answered 21 Jan '13, 07:04

Jaianniah's gravatar image


What is a hallucination?

(21 Jan '13, 10:02) flowsurfer

@flowsurfer- I am confused. What do you specifically need explained- hallucinations in general? or the fact that a three-year-old is not capable of hallucinating??? Total confusion here....Jai

(21 Jan '13, 17:39) Jaianniah

Yes, you are confused. If you believe some experiences are "hallucinations" and some are "real", you are deluded if you believe a child cannot hallucinate; children hallucinate often because their brainwaves are closer to a dream state and their sensations are not well integrated. What you experienced is a well known phenomenon called lucid dreaming and you are only assuming that it means what you think it means.

(21 Jan '13, 17:47) flowsurfer

You would have to have an experience which actually had some sort of cause/effect relationship with your everyday experience to come even close to "proving" to yourself anything of the sort.

(21 Jan '13, 17:48) flowsurfer

An example would be the experiences that Neville Goddard claimed to have. He used his imagination to create an effect in the world which proved to him that there was no such thing as a "hallucination", only two different spheres of experience, the natural and the spiritual, which were not separate but deeply connected. All so-called hallucinations, regardless of how they are achieved, are spiritual experiences.

(21 Jan '13, 17:51) flowsurfer

@flowsurfer- I choose to believe the experience was REAL. I use the word "hallucination" to DIFFERENTIATE it from a dream, lucid or not. I know it was real- I saw real people doing real things while outside my body- I saw my father working in the garage, and told him that I saw him while I was flying. I should not have to argue my reality with anyone.

(21 Jan '13, 18:05) Jaianniah

@flowsurfer- This phenomenon has been experienced by many- it is called an OBE. You must know that. To me, it proves we have souls. I refuse to argue semantics any further with you.

(21 Jan '13, 18:06) Jaianniah

I'm not saying it was not real, I'm saying it was precisely as real as a dream. An OBE is a dream; or if you want to put it another way, a dream is an OBE. This is regardless of its quality. If dreams are real or not, I don't know.

(21 Jan '13, 18:31) flowsurfer
showing 2 of 8 show 6 more comments

spirituality exist you just need to experience it. but if your awareness is only on the outside you do not see what is on the inside. then you do not know your self. and because you do not know your self you do not know other. and it gives the world that you are experiencing now.

the more you will know your self and the more you will know other.and the better you can make wise decision with your free will.

but if you do not know your self you live in poverty and you are that poverty.

how can you live a good life in harmony if you fear other and think that they want to hurt you. even if they try to help you you will reject them judge them and be afraid of them. to the mesure you judge also will you be judge. so is that what you want in life?

you allready have seen that is what is happening in your life right now is it not?

do you think still think that it is only a merely psycological defense mecanisms?

or a knowledge of the inner and the outer in truth to solve the duality?

as to convince you or make you believe what ever you want,that belong to you and is part of your free will.

and if you believe that we are not telling you the truth take the blue pill go to sleep and you can believe what ever you want.


answered 21 Jan '13, 01:27

white%20tiger's gravatar image

white tiger

edited 21 Jan '13, 01:28

I am not afraid of people, I am afraid of God. I don't judge you. There are some judgemental reactions that sometimes pop up but I don't take them seriously. You on the other hand is full of judgement. The only duality is between Man and God; Man is experience, the effect of God which is cause, or reality. God is the external which shapes man, the internal. Man is a screen of consciousness, within that screen an experience takes place which is the Word of God, his conversation with Man.

(21 Jan '13, 01:43) flowsurfer

Awareness cannot be on the "outside" or the "inside" because that distinction is illusory. The World is not separate from God, it is God, seen from our perspective as Man.

(21 Jan '13, 01:49) flowsurfer

@flowsurfer go find a place to sit and go there each day to wait for God,keep watch.if you are willing to end your life then you should have no problem to wait for God.well if you are afraid of God that is because you are darkness right now.when you should be light.i am only telling you the truth.but you do not accept my testimony.

(21 Jan '13, 01:56) white tiger
showing 2 of 3 show 1 more comments
Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website



Asked: 20 Jan '13, 17:39

Seen: 764 times

Last updated: 21 Jan '13, 18:32

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here



Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text]( "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Related Questions