Father,Son,Holy spirt. three differnt persons that form ONE god. How many agree and how many disagree??

I personally do agree because for evryhting that is unique and essential for life comes in three, for example. H20 being the molecular formula that is water is divided into three SEPERATE elements yet CONSISTS of the same molecular formula...h20(water). And with water comes the liquid form, ice the solid form, and steam the gas form. even though all are SEPERATE elements they still are of the SAME SOURCE....WATER!

and you can also use humans for example. even though we are only ONE physical being, we have 3 SEPERATE ASPECTS TO US. MIND, BODY, AND SOUL! even though these three are SEPERATE aspects of that physical being, they still are of the SAME BEING! (person).

so as you can see, if WE have these three aspects THAT FORM our being, and us being made in GODS IMAGE, then of course this concept must ALSO APPLY TO GOD ALMIGHTY!


asked 15 Feb '10, 05:27

Mebb's gravatar image


edited 15 Feb '10, 07:27

Barry%20Allen's gravatar image

Barry Allen ♦♦

Hi Mebb, I agree with the statements you have made. I would also like to add to your explanation a little further.

Years ago when I honestly looked at this question, this is what I found.

It was said that the doctrine of the Trinity teaches that there is one God, yet three distinct persons, each person is the same in substance and equal in and power and glory .

I had discovered an interesting verse in the bible that helped me understand the trinity question more clearly. Hope this will help you.

In Roman 1:20 it says, (I have included verse 19 to show its context)

19: Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. 20: For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:

Basically this is saying that, we can understand the invisible things of him by the things that are made/created or in other words by what we physically see and comprehend. This most definitely includes understanding his eternal power and Godhead as it is stated in verse 20.

Definition: Godhead n. 1. Divinity; godhood. 2. Godhead a) The Christian God, especially the Trinity. b) The essential and divine nature of God, regarded abstractly. (The union of the Father and Son and Holy Ghost in one Godhead)(http://www.thefreedictionary.com/godhead)

The trinity is regarded abstractly for those that do not comprehend its nature or make-up.

So back to the question, How can we understand the trinity (the invisible thing) with what God created (what we can see).

The universe is basically made up of 3 parts. Einstein's theory of relativity revealed the fact that life as we know it consists of three things, time, matter, and space (which is energy).

If one of these elements were removed, the universe as we know it would cease to exist. All three elements are needed so the universe can be (i.e. exist).

Each of these 3 elements (time, matter and space) in turn are made up of 3 parts also.

Time is made up of 3 parts. They are; the past, present and future. If one of these elements were removed, time as we know it would cease to exist. If there is no past the present could not advance into the future to create a past. If there were no present, there definitely would not be a past and future. If there was no future, the present would not be able to move forward.

Matter is made up of atoms. All atoms consist of three basic components, protons, neutrons and electrons. A proton is not a neutron, a neutron is not an electron, and an electron is not a proton. One is not the other, all are part of the same, none can exist without the other (and still remain a complete atom), and yet each is distinct!

Matter is invisible at its core yet we can perceive it.

Two thousand years ago the writer of Hebrew's wrote:

Heb. 11:3 By faith we understand that the worlds were prepared by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things which are visible.

Re-read this until you understand what it saying. By faith we understand...that*,* what is seen*,* was not made*,* out of things which are visible.

(Side note: If man wrote the bible, how could he write something that he didn't know about. We only discovered atoms at the invention of powerful microscopes. Man is catching up to the bible. This is one example of the divine inspiration of the scriptures.)

We now know this to be a fact because of microscopes. When things are magnified to its minutest level we found it to be energy.

Matter is made up of 3 parts. They are; gases, solids and liquids. If one of these elements were removed, matter as we know it would cease to exist. As an example, take water. In this form it is a liquid. If the element of gases were to be removed, matter as we know it would cease to exist because you would not be able to boil water which once boiled turns into a gas. If solids were to be removed, matter as we know it would cease to exist, because water in a liquid form when frozen would not be able to become/transform into a solid.

Space is made up of 3 parts. They are; length, width and height. Look to the upper corner part of the room you're in right now and notice the three 'walls' i.e. the ceiling, the wall going to the left and the one going to the right. Each wall has an element to it. One supplies the length, one supplies the width and one supplies the height. These three elements make up the concept of space or 3 dimensions. If one of these elements were removed, space as we know it would cease to exist.

A question now comes up. In this example of space, which element (length, width or height) is the most important or which element is the greatest and which is the least?

Would you say that they are all equally the same and important? Could one element be the head or number 1?

When we perceive the 'space' in a room, we realize that no one element can be greater than another. They all perform the duty they were created to do.

Space is an invisible concept yet we comprehend it by the walls we built around ourselves.

Here is another way to explain it:

Space is a trinity of elements: the length, the width, and the height. The length is not the same element as the width; the width is not the same element as the height; and the height is not the same element as the length. They are separate elements; yet, they are all the one space. They are in absolute perfect harmony consisting of one substance. They are coequal, and copowerful. If any one of the three were removed, there would be no space.

Using the above logic, I now apply it to the concept of the trinity.

God is a trinity of persons: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. The Father is not the same person as the Son; the Son is not the same person as the Holy Ghost; and the Holy Ghost is not the same person as Father. They are separate persons; yet, they are all the one God. They are in absolute perfect harmony consisting of one substance. They are coeternal, coequal, and copowerful. If any one person of the three were removed, there would be no God.

1 John 5:7 For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one.

Main stream thought about the trinity is that 1+1+1=3. Their basic premise is that three persons cannot make one person (visible form). The trinity should not be added but multiplied i.e. 1x1x1=1. The premise for this is that when one calculates volume, you multiply the length by the width by the height. This gives you the total space of a given area (invisible form).


Some other examples of tri-unity in unity.

Man is triune in nature. He is made up of a spirit, a soul, and a body. The moment that one of these elements is taken out or removed, man as we know him, ceases to exist (in this plane).

1 Thessalonians 5:23 And the very God of peace sanctify you wholly; and I pray God your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.

How about the human mind?

Scientists tell us that the human mind is the most complex thing in the universe. The is also a trinity. The mind, the will, and the emotions. Your mind, (intellect) is not the same as your emotions. Your emotions are not the same as your will. One is not the other, all are part of the same, none can exist without the other, and yet each is distinct!


Someone had made this observation about the sun once.

Direct sunlight has a luminous efficacy of about 93 lumens per watt of radiant flux, which includes infrared, visible, and ultraviolet light. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunlight)

Infrared light can be felt but not seen. (Holy Ghost) Visible light can be seen and felt. (The Son) Ultraviolet light can't be seen or felt. (The Father)

There are other examples I have that I can use. I hope you have enough information here to help you begin to comprehend and grasp this concept of the trinity.

All the best.


answered 25 Mar '10, 06:35

Frank%201's gravatar image

Frank 1

edited 25 Mar '10, 14:21

Hello, Frank... You are absolutely correct with your observations of 3 aspects working independently yet still being an equal part of a whole unit. For example, in the action of stealing, a person may be doing the physical action (body) while talking to himself (soul) and feeling guilty about it (spirit). All 3 aspects of the person are present (body, soul, and spirit), equal, and working independently. However, it is still ONE person doing the stealing. Also, your breakdown of the sun's radiation spectrum was very enjoyable. Thanks for reading.

(12 Jun '10, 03:05) Concerned Citizen

I think Kabbala explains this concept quite well - and there is a Christian Cabbala.

Kether, Chokmah and Binah - which can be described as Father, Son and Holy Ghost. Also these three are 'reflected' at the level of manifestation... as we try to be a reflection of Our Father who art in Heaven.

Kabbala/Cabbala/Qabala is not for the faint hearted... but it you take it a little at a time and see where your personal belief system fits in - it can be a very useful tool.

Alchemy/Hermetics/Kabbala/Christianity etc etc ... all say the same thing. By trying to understand one you start to understand the other.

It was only when I studied Latin that my Enlish grammar improved. It was only when I studied horticulture that my understanding of the human body improved. It was only when I started to study the symbols and stories of many different cultures that my understanding of the Bible improved. Mountains, valleys, temples, plains, forests .. all have other meanings.

Three persons cannot make one other person no matter how mystical. I would have to vote that there are three parts to God.

We are body, soul and spirit and one person. Maybe the Trinity is something along those lines, but so far above our capacity to comprehend that we might never be able to adequately explain it.


answered 15 Feb '10, 06:32

Inactive%20User's gravatar image

Inactive User ♦♦

I was thinking about this question again last night.. and the symbol of the point within the circle came to mind. Point - Circumference - interactive area between the two (Holy Ghost?).

(15 Feb '10, 22:16) Inactive User ♦♦

(John 1: 1) In the beginning was the word; the word was with God, and God was the word. And it when on to say that everything was created by the power of the word by God!

Jesus said: I am in the father, and the father is in me! The son is in the father; the father is in the son; and they both came from the same spirit source God, the soul of all creation. God created man out of clay, giving man a physical body; he breathe the breath of life into man nostrils giving man life to breathe, life, and function as a human being; he also gave man the spirit of language to speak; and a soul that will never die, because it is from the same spirit source God, the soul of all creation.

So based upon what we know, don’t know, or what we want to believe, and if I may dare say, the truth is the truth, and the truth may be different to everyone. But nonetheless, God is God; the son is the son; and the Holy Ghost is the spirit. They are three different things from the same source; therefore, they are one, and the same thing. The father, the son, and the Holy Ghost! Of course, it is called the Holy Trinity.

Regardless, of how you may want to look at it, the fact is, everything is indeed from the same source, the first cause, and everything in life is very spiritual, that is why life remains a mystery based upon the spiritual aspect of all living things, and our existing Universe.

You can be your own best judge in terms of what you believe the Holy Trinity to be, but in essence there is only one God, one source, and one truth. An example: The truth is everyone’s blood is the same color “Red,” why, because we are all one, and same human, and all humans have blood in their veins, and the color is red; and it is also a fact of life that we cannot change this truth, but we must accept it, why, because we do not have a choice; it is what it is, and this is the way we are created!


answered 15 Feb '10, 08:24

Inactive%20User's gravatar image

Inactive User ♦♦

edited 25 Mar '10, 17:18

Wade%20Casaldi's gravatar image

Wade Casaldi

Hi Vee, in your first point the reference is John 1:1 not Genesis 1:1

(24 Mar '10, 23:01) Frank 1

Vee don't worry I fixed that for you, it is John 1:1 :-D

(25 Mar '10, 17:20) Wade Casaldi

I have this theory that they are different levels of representation.

  1. Jesus is the avatar of God (like Neo when he is in the Matrix)

  2. The Holy Spirit is the avatar of the Father God in the spiritual world (or vice-versa, I don't know)

  3. One of them is the ultimate reality above the physical and the spiritual world

I wrote about this in my blog


answered 15 Feb '10, 15:29

Jader%20Dias's gravatar image

Jader Dias

edited 21 Feb '10, 18:21

My own concept of "The Trinity" is the conscious, the inconscious or subconscious, and the heart. When these three are all together, you are able to make miracles. When I do cross sign, I often say: in the name of conscious (what I want consciously) in the name of the subconscious (what I want inside of me very deap) and in the name of my heart: what my heart wants me to do. If I obtain unicity... It's won. In the LOA trinity is for me: 1) what you ask 2) what you believe 3) what you receive. Excuse my poor english, I shall improve it's promished!


answered 15 Feb '10, 18:14

Le%20B%C3%A9mo's gravatar image

Le Bémo

With Huna what you are saying is catagorised as the conscious self, the subconscious self and the great parental self. To have prayers answered the conscious self must accumulate enough 'energy' to contact the subconscious, which decides whether or not to pass on the request to the Aumakhua (the Parental Overself). It is only -when these three do meet and agree in perfect unity that the request is granted. A study of Huna can be very rewarding, especially Maxwell Freedom Long's books about it.

(15 Feb '10, 22:26) Inactive User ♦♦

I like what was told to Patricia King through the Holy Spirit, it is God's spirit man self, in other words the most personal part of God, God gave us that too. The true essence from which we come is our Spirit man the Holy Spirit is God's true essence self, that core being of God. God loves us so much he left nothing from us he even gave us his true essence self, his spirit man self.

This makes a lot of sense since the Holy spirit is held in such high esteem in the Bible that this is most personal to God's nature of existence, just as our spirit man is most personal to our existence.

The closest I can think of to represent this is if we said to a friend i am going to let you access my brain, you can access my conscious, my subconscious and even my supra conscious mind. That is a lot many would say wait you can't know what I did as a child, or what I did last year when I was at my lowest. But God hid nothing and said I give you everything my entire self, so the same we give God when we chose to be reborn in the Holy Spirit as a new creation of God's love.


answered 25 Mar '10, 17:30

Wade%20Casaldi's gravatar image

Wade Casaldi

edited 26 Mar '10, 06:01

Hi Wade where in the bible did you notice that the Holy spirit is held in such high esteem? I'm not familiar with the passage. My study of this subject is that all 3 parts are equal on all levels.

Also, when God gives, he gives all that he is of himself to man. Not a part as you explained. God gave the Son (John 3:16). The Son gave his life (John 15:13-14) and God gave the Holy Spirit (1Thessalonians 4:8). All 3 parts of the Godhead work in unison.

If you've noticed differently in the bible, show me where, that I may correct my knowledge of the subject. I may have overlooked some passages.

(25 Mar '10, 18:15) Frank 1

for Frank Luke 13 If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children: how much more shall your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to them that ask him? Mark 3:29
But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost hath never forgiveness, but is in danger of eternal damnation:

(26 Mar '10, 05:55) Wade Casaldi

Hey Wade, your first passage is in Luke 11 not 13. I'm familiar with these verses. I don't see where the Holy Spirit is held in high esteem. The context of Luke 11 is about prayer (verse 1). Basically, you receive the Holy Spirit by asking for it in prayer to God. The context of Mark 3(22-30) is accusing Jesus to cast out devils by the power of Beelzebub when in fact it was done by the power of the Holy Spirit. Blasphemy against the Holy Ghost is saying that the Holy Spirit is an unclean spirit. Nowhere do I see the Spirit being held in high esteem...

(26 Mar '10, 19:51) Frank 1

...In your answer you wrote, "the Holy spirit is held in such high esteem", Do you mean that the Holy Spirit is higher or more important than the Son & Father? Can you clarify this point so I may know what your thoughts are and/or what your understanding is. Also, how does your answer relate or explain the concept of The Trinity? You focused on The Holy Spirit only. So what is the trinity to you?

(26 Mar '10, 20:00) Frank 1

I see it The Holy Spirit as important by those scriptures, but that could be just my interpretation that it is important. Not more important than the Father & Son I see the three as one each needing the other to be, but if you feel it is less important I guess it is just a matter of personal interpretation. I focused on the Holy Spirit because it is not known or understood as much as the Father and Son. We happened to be doing a bible study on the Holy Spirit at my church so that fit in with the question.

(27 Mar '10, 06:18) Wade Casaldi

Hey Wade, it's not that I see it as less important. In my first comment I mentioned that all 3 parts are co-equal. Also, read my answer. As pertaining to the point that the Holy Spirit is not known or understood as much as the Father and Son, I don't really see that in scripture. In my study of the trinity I have noticed that all 3 parts of the Godhead are actively involved in everything that is done. Eg. All three parts resurrected Jesus. There are many more examples I can give. All 3 parts also have distinct duties and responsibilities. Enough info is given on each to know about them.

(27 Mar '10, 12:45) Frank 1

Oh then we agree the Holy spirit is held in high esteem just as the Father and Son are. Here is a way I like to think of the trinity if I have a cube it has height, width, and depth, all three are needed for that cube to exist or really anything in our reality needs all three to exist. The interesting thing is on a computer screen we can drop down to two dimensions but that is digressing. So all three need each other to be. That is why it is so important like a chair missing a leg can't stand all three are important.

(27 Mar '10, 16:33) Wade Casaldi

I really like your cube example. It's easy for anyone to comprehend. Don't mind if I use your example.

(27 Mar '10, 22:29) Frank 1

No not at all Frank, go ahead and use it if you like, I know I give you votes because I like your answers too. I enjoyed this and it helped clarify and reveal more than original thank you.

(28 Mar '10, 04:31) Wade Casaldi

I'm glad my answers are clearing questions. Hopefully I'll be able to answer more questions as time affords.

(28 Mar '10, 17:22) Frank 1
showing 2 of 10 show 8 more comments








answered 28 Mar '10, 17:36

John%20Milo's gravatar image

John Milo

Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website

Related Questions