According to the idea of Karma, your soul comes back to life as a reward or punishment of your previous life. So, if you have behaved bad in this life you will come back as a lower being or you will live a life of illnes or misfortune.

Now, I have being reading The Law of Attraction by Esther and Jerry Hicks, and Abraham doesn't even hint at that, as far as I understand it.

He says that our Soul wishes to come back to live a new and different experience from the previous ones, and so improving itself each time. He never mentions punishment or reward... Am I mistaken in my interpretation? Reincarnation, is or isn't Karmic?

I'd like to hear your opinion on the subject...


asked 25 Jun '10, 13:52

BridgetJones09's gravatar image


I'm sure you will have noticed an underlying theme in all of my postings to this group over the past several months.

That theme is that we live in an ordered, consistent and understandable Universe.

And I think it will serve you well if you remember that theme whenever you are confronted with those who spread Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt.

I was beaten over the head for years with this Karma idea of punishment and reward and, for a while, I believed what I was told.

I was told that if I ever did something wrong, I would pay for it later at some unknown time in some unknown way. Strangely enough, no-one ever defined exactly what wrong meant but, funnily enough, wrong always seemed to be aligned with the arbitrary moral values of the person talking to me.

So I was confronted with this idea that kept me constantly worried and fearful that I would do something wrong and be punished. And it made me miserable and depressed.

But wait a minute...if I was now miserable and depressed, I thought to myself at that time, this feels like punishment doesn't it?

And so, I reasoned, that can only mean that I did something wrong previously in a past life - because I'm pretty sure that I haven't been that bad in this one. I figured I must have been a pretty awful person to be suffering so much.

So the result is that I suffered even more because now, not only was I being punished, I was also a bad person in a previous life.

For me, this mental state went on for years as I blindly accepted the wisdom of people regarding Karma, even though none of them could answer my questions about exactly how Karma worked or what I could do to get rid of it. (It's like when some extremely religious people tell you that you must not question what they say - you must simply accept it.)

And strangely enough, I noticed no-one else around me living particularly happy lives either, even though they were apparently spiritual people. In fact, most of them seemed miserable and unhappy too...obviously, they must be being punished too for being bad people in previous lives. There seemed to be a lot of currently-good, but previously bad, people around within the spiritual circles I moved in.

Then one day I had an encounter with a tall being of white light which I have described previously on this website.

From that day, everything changed for me. Everything.

I started to question things that I had been told I should not question. I started to look at things I was told I should not look at. I started to talk to people who I was told I should not talk to.

My search was relentless. That being of light had made me feel empowered for the first time in my life for many, many years.

And, as that feeling of relentless empowerment began to dominate my consciousness, my world started to change. Answers to things I had always wanted to know started to flood in, even to things which I had been told there were no answers for.

I'm sure you will have realized by now from what I've written that it was that feeling of depression that had prevented me from finding those answers before because the Law of Attraction was only bringing me more circumstances to match that feeling.

And once I felt empowered, I started to attract empowering people, situations and knowledge. I even stumbled across Abraham...since the knowledge that was previously there under my nose was now a vibrational match to how I felt and it entered my reality.

Now I make it a point in my life to empower people whenever they are attracted into my reality. I've learned myself that just giving people that little bit of hope that they are not trapped in their life circumstances - that they are not victims - is really all that it takes to start them on a life-changing process. I'm just passing on what that being of light did for me.

So now, let's come back to Karma and all the punishment/reward stuff...

  • Does Karma seem like an empowering concept to you or a dis-empowering concept to you? Do the people who tell you that you must believe in it seem empowered or dis-empowered to you? What does your gut tell you about them?

  • Has anyone ever explained to you exactly how Karma works? Or do they just give you vague answers and avoid the subject of the mechanics of Karma? Do their arguments seem like spaghetti to you...all a mish-mash of intertwined endless looping and twisting? And you know how hard it is to eat spaghetti? :)

alt text

  • There is a method on this website called Focus Blocks that will take any thought, move it into a better place and bring different manifestations into your life as a result. It works for anyone who sincerely tries it. So if all these thoughts and their subsequent manifestations are under your precise control, where did the Karma go?

  • If you accept that the Law of Attraction exists and it is true that we attract into our lives whatever is in alignment with our dominant thoughts then, again, where did the Karma go?

  • Metaphysically speaking, everything that happens in the Universe actually happens simultaneously. Outside of our limited focus in this physical reality, the past, present and future are all actually happening now. Yes, it's a mind-blowing concept that may take you a while to internalize but the point is that if everything is happening now how can Karma exist in the way that people understand it? There was no past in which to do bad things because the past is Now!

  • What does your emotional guidance tell you about the concept of this mysterious Karma. Do you feel good when you think about it, or does it make you feel bad?

You might be wondering why this answer is so questioning and just based so much on my personal experience and thoughts. Why can I not precisely come up with a simple set of statements that disprove that Karma exists?

Simple reason - how can you disprove the existence of something when no-one shows you how to find it?...I don't have anything concrete to disprove because no-one will come up with the exact explanation of how Karma works that can be disproven.

So, until the day that happens, and someone who puts forward this punishment/reward Karma idea actually reveals its apparent method of operation, all that I can do is resort to anecdotal evidence.

It's a bit like someone telling you that the sun may not rise up tomorrow into the sky, but they won't tell you the exact rules that will govern when it will come up and when it doesn't.

So when the sun does rise and you tell them they got it wrong, they simply tell you that the rules for it not to rise were not satisfied so it did rise that day. But tomorrow, it may not rise :)

You can't win when people draw you into playing that game, and that's probably why this nonsense Karma concept manages to perpetuate.

So there you have it. I can't disprove Karma to you but I can suggest some thoughts (as hopefully I have done) that may cause you to question what you are told about it now and in the future.

And, finally, since you mentioned Abraham, I would like to share with you what Abraham think of Karma...and I think they sum it up very well. :)

Abraham's blunt and direct view of Karma


answered 26 Jun '10, 08:14

Stingray's gravatar image


edited 26 Jun '10, 08:40

I don't buy into karma or punishment from previous lives. But what's your take on learning lessons from past mistakes in this life? I don't think we can really expand and grow unless we learn , from our mistakes, along the way. I think every experience happens to teach us something and if we don't get the lesson it will come back later in another guise. Or are you saying that when we master the Law of Attraction, we'll live a completely idyllic life with no obstacles or challenges?

(26 Jun '10, 13:09) Michaela

@Michaela, a mistake implies you've done something wrong and it also implies a learning curriculum. But who is to judge what is wrong and what is right? And who is setting up the lessons to be learned? If you think we are here to learn lessons, please explain to me clearly how this lessons thing works, I'm really interested to get some detail on this :) I would say, instead, that we incarnate to constantly decipher the contrast of physical reality to find excuses to experience joy. Sure, the universe expands as a symbiotic by-product but that's not what our physical focus is about.

(26 Jun '10, 16:04) Stingray

@Stingray, I know right and wrong are personal perceptions and I guess we set those lessons,ourselves, by the choices we make.However I guess I differ in my opinion from you, right now , in that although I agree we do decipher the contrast to find ways to expereience joy, I think we are also here to grow and expand and to be the best version of ourselves that we can be and this often entails learning new ways of being and acting ( toward ourselves and others) that previously we may not have known. This could mean anything from learning to be compassionate to learning to love and treat all

(26 Jun '10, 16:39) Michaela

sentient beings equally - so I guess I think the whole human experience is more than just experiencing joy although I do agree that's a very valid part and even deciphering the contrast and finding new ways to experience joy, is a learning process.

(26 Jun '10, 16:41) Michaela

@Michaela - I agree with you. But that growth and expansion is not something we need to concern ourselves with consciously. Our non-physical counterpart - The Higher Self - understands clearly whatever broader themes we wish to play with. But our only requirement for all that to happen is to feel joy. We are like a chauffeur in a car. Our job is just to drive, not to question where we are going...leave that to the boss to decide. :) When we start trying to drive and also decide - when it is not our job - we get lost :)

(27 Jun '10, 08:18) Stingray

@Stingray-Ok, so if I see or feel that I made a mistake along the way, I shouldn't consciously try to rectify it? Describing us like chauffeurs makes me feel like we're puppets with someone else pulling the strings - I think I'd rather be the passenger than the chauffeur. By the way thanks for taking the time for this exchange, even though I don't always agree, I love the exchange of ideas and new food for thought :-)

(27 Jun '10, 12:51) Michaela

No, you shouldn't try to consciously rectify it. You should aim for joy and allow inspiration from there to guide you. If anything needs fixing, your Higher Self will guide you to it...but you must aim for Joy! The thing to bear in mind is that the whole you = the physical you + your Higher Self. You work as one unit together with different jobs. Feeling good means alignment with that Higher Self - it means you are letting it do its job of guiding you. It is still You in control, it's just that people think that the you is only physical and you are so much more than that.

(27 Jun '10, 12:56) Stingray

Definitely something to mull over - maybe time to peel another layer of that onion! Thanks :-)

(27 Jun '10, 13:13) Michaela

Stingray, everything changed for me when I was visited by a beautiful angel surrounded and filled with the most amazing blue light....I would love to compare notes sometime....I think she was Mary. She had a GREAT effect on my life. As you said, everything changed. Everything! Blessings, Jai P.S. 303 characters just is not enough to say what happened that night, but it was the most beautiful experience. I felt such endless peace....

(28 Jun '10, 03:02) Jaianniah

First of all, I wanna thank @Stingray and @Michaela for the debate. A LOT can be learned by the exchange of opinions, when done in a respectful manner as is customary here. That for once. @Stingray: As I was brought up as a Christian first I was haunted with the Heaven/Hell idea. I don't know how it happened, you always seem to be heading for Hell headforemost. Then if you were really really lucky you were sent to Purgatory insted. Which wasn't tempting either. You would have need to be a Saint to deserve Heaven the way they put it. Then the idea started rolling that God was...

(28 Jun '10, 14:00) BridgetJones09

...all-forgiving and at the last moment he would send us all to Heaven. Then why was the point of scaring you with Hell? I started doing research on other religions to see if I could find and answer that made more sense. Tryied the Quran and it didn't resonate with me. Then there was Hinduism. And the idea of Karma haunted me even in a worse way than Hell did!!! From this line of yours: "So I was confronted with this idea that kept me constantly worried and fearful that I would do something wrong and be punished. And it made me miserable and depressed." onwards I have been totally there!!!

(28 Jun '10, 14:08) BridgetJones09

And then you've made a very good point of all that afterwards. I've just watched Abraham's video and couldn't less than laugh!!! :D Thank you for posting it! PS: I have read the other post where you were treated as an evil being trying to pervert us, as if we weren't able to think for ourselves!!! I tried to find that post but wasn't able. To me, in any case, sounds hilarious. :D The idea!!! @Jaiannia: You seem a very gifted person. I admire you, really! xxx

(28 Jun '10, 14:23) BridgetJones09

@BridgetJones: The other evil beings post. - While I don't agree with the opinions expressed regarding evil beings trying to trick us by helping us (?), I can understand the helpful intent of the people making these posts, so I don't wish to sound disrepectful towards them in any way. It's just that I personally believe the points of view expressed are based on erroneous assumptions and therefore lead to erroneous conclusions

(28 Jun '10, 17:24) Stingray

I am beginning to see that everyone has the wrong idea about Karma. Think of it as positive and negative energy and nirvana as neutral or the absence of energy. When they talk about Karmic energy they are talking about the energy you are projecting with your negative or positive thoughts. Like attracts like and opposites do repel. Reaching Nirvana is to attain a neutral energy or the absence of energy so the universe can fill you with pure energy. Having a positive or negative energy blocks the flow of universal energy. just like atoms have positive, negative and neutral charges.

(03 Jul '10, 20:50) Goodisevil

Many of you have discussed seeing beings of light and/or meeting enlightened ones that have steered you to a better place/path. How do you know they have your best interest in mind? When I say the universe will fill you with pure energy, it is the best or closest I can describe what happens as I have no words for it. Is this not what you try to achieve with balancing your chakras to raise your vibrational levels to a higher pitch? Isn't it amazing that you can clear your mind by concentrating on different parts of your body and associating a color and tone to it. There is a connection, look

(03 Jul '10, 21:04) Goodisevil

When I say evil beings do you automatically associate them with the paranormal or metaphysical realm of existance. Is it possible that they may exist in the natural world we live in as solid flesh and blood beings. Do you believe in UFO's and extraterrestials? I have seen crafts in the sky that I can't identify as terrestial. Have you met an ET? Do you know what there agenda may be? Is it possible they may have the ability to communicate by telepathy and influence beings of lesser mental capacity? Why do you automatically assume they are benevolent and not malevolent. What about abductions?

(03 Jul '10, 21:16) Goodisevil

Here, lets take a current event and put a little spin on it to see what you think. Gulf oil spill, they could have brought a rig in and run a drill string down the hole they already have after cutting away the mangled pipe and plugged it in the first month. The ship "The Whale" was retro fitted after the spill to help with the clean up. Look closely at it and you will realize it takes months to make the changes to the ship they said only took, what 3 weeks and sailing two weeks to get there. Now, does this sound like it was accidental or on purpose? Who are you going to believe?

(03 Jul '10, 21:42) Goodisevil

My point is that you have to look inside yourself and find the truth to what is really going on in the spiritual, metaphysical and natural world. I can give advice but are you going to listen to me or the person who knows how to manipulate your being. And yes there are beings natural and maybe supernatural that don't want you to know the truth. United we stand, divided we fall is just as true today as it was the day it was first uttered. until we unite together as one, we are doomed to fail and be conquered. May God have mercy on us all.

(03 Jul '10, 21:49) Goodisevil

If you want to know what I am talking about read the above 5 post. You asked about it and I am answering your question. Be so kind as to respond so I know you read my replies.

(06 Jul '10, 23:28) Goodisevil

What is it you would like me to reply to? As I've been saying for many months now, Good Feels Good. What aspect of that is unclear?

(07 Jul '10, 03:29) Stingray

True, but the question was about Karma and evil beings. Your statement about asking a question about beings with bad intentions and what affect Karma truly played in our lives was never answered by those you questioned about it. I have provided my answer to your query. And I still ask how can you or anyone truly know if your angel/spirit guide/visitor really has your best interest in mind and not a hidden agenda. I point out the spanish inqusition and all the people killed by the church or the salem witch trials as the basis for my screen name. Just because it feels good doesn't make it right.

(09 Jul '10, 06:56) Goodisevil

@Goodisevil, the Good Feels Good was actually my answer to your suggestion that no-one can know for sure if they are being misled. I've since expanded those three words into a more detailed answer here: . See if that makes things clearer for you

(09 Jul '10, 19:07) Stingray

@Stingray- You are God dude. We're just on the internet here and you empower me every time :)

(13 Jun '12, 22:20) Nikulas

"...funnily enough, wrong always seemed to be aligned with the arbitrary moral values of the person talking to me." Yes, seeing this is a pivotal point, in my opinion.

Right is right if it feels right, as my feelings are my measure in all things, for who could know better than me? When you are taught from the cradle to ignore, suppress, and generally disrespect your own feelings, this is quite a leap.

(03 May '14, 13:23) Grace
showing 2 of 24 show 22 more comments

Hi Bridget,

Remember when you were a child and You got so caught up in playing a game with your friends that you just wouldn't come home? Your mother would urge you "Bridget, it's time for supper" and you would just yell "5 more minutes, Mom." and come back to playing the game..

That's how I view Karma; you get so caught up in playing the game that you just won't let it go. You won't to get better each time you play but you are so anxious to come back that more often than not you don't take the time to reflect on what went wrong in that lifetime and how to improve it.

As I read a lot of books by Dolores Cannon, which is a past life regressionist, she was able to tap into the knowledge of the Spirit world directly to the Source, from the Spirits that were occupying it and what she found out was something like this - You always have a choice to come back and you always have assistance on the other side. Assistance is in the form of Masters ans Teachers who show you what you did and what lessons you learned and which you didn't. Than the Masters SUGGEST to you what scenario or life would be good to live next to learn the lessons you didn't in the previous lifetime.

So if you were someone who abused power of any kind you might choose a lifetime of someone who is powerless. for example someone in a wheelchair who is dependent on others and stuff like that. It doesn't mean that if you killed someone you HAVE TO get killed also, but maybe help people who have lost someone close and stuff like that. So it isn't LITERAL as most of us might think.

So what happened on this Earth? Well, we got so caught up in playing the game that some of us were so anxious that they didn't listen to the Masters and Teachers. They went to the other side and instead waiting to learn they said "Ok, ok, I've get it. Let me back in. I want to try again." And puff, you're here, because you always CHOOSE your experience and all the things others do are just suggestions and NOT orders you have to follow.

So in this day and age that we are living right now it is much easier not to get caught up in the Karma of past lifetimes. As more and more people start to awaken you can integrate more and more of the lessons that you failed to learn before, and Presto! Suddenly you've learned lessons that took you several lifetimes in just few months. And the process will keep on speeding up as we go along.

It does that because every person that awakens doesn't add up the positive energy for change, but it multiplies it. So 2 people working together on positive changes can overpower 4 negative people, 3 positives overpower 3^2=9 negatives, 4 positives overpower 4^2=16 negatives and so on, so there really doesn't have to be so many positive people to tip the scales if you say for the "good side of the Force".

And Karma, well, it's self-imposed. If you believe that previous lifetimes can hold some power over you, then well, they will. But when you don't buy into that and say "Well, the lifetime that I'm living now it's the most important one for me and let me focus on this one" than that's the effect you will get out of it.

You can CHOOSE it, really. Just say "Let others worry about that Karma stuff and I will enjoy my life as it is now." It doesn't mean that you won't learn the lessons that you needed to learn previously, but it will be that much easier and effortless, because you won't be digging through hundreds of previous lifetimes but just focus on this lifetime and responses that come up to day-to-day affairs. Once you do that you will "get off" that wheel of Karma that many people have been on for so long and just enjoy life for what it is .. a beautiful and exciting ride, where all that matters is the Now.


answered 25 Jun '10, 18:10

wildlife's gravatar image


Inspiring answer.

(25 Jun '10, 20:03) Asklepios

Thank you wildlife! I found your answer very uplifting and the example of my mum calling me in moved me. I have always found the idea of karma very bleak! Only when I read 'The Law of Attraction' I knew it didn't necessary have to be like that. That's why I thought I would ask ppl's opinion on the subject! BJ09

(28 Jun '10, 13:44) BridgetJones09

karma and all that is written about it is a law of nature also known as cause and effect. reincarnation and all that is written about it is a cyclic journey into manifestation of a form of life (spark of energy) evolving towards perfection.


answered 26 Jun '10, 13:53

fred's gravatar image


I disagree with wildlife, karma according to the hindu and buddhist faith is a punishment for being too good or too bad, which results in your reincarnation on this world and the vessel you are put into is determined by your karma. in order to break the cycle you must reach nirvana as buddha did by being neutral and giving up all wants and desires. This will bring you into oneness with the universe which is both positive and negative and yet neither.

People can be decieved by demons and evil beings from attaining nirvana as Mara tried to do with Siddhartha, but Siddhartha was able to stay the course and not be distracted from attaining nirvana.

Just as Satan tried to turn Jesus against GOD when he was fasting in the desert. They want you to fail and not reach your full potential. That is why they offer so many different views and call them all the truth to confuse and turn you from the right path. You must open your mind to the truth by meditating and becoming an empty shell for GOD/UNIVERSE to fill with a wonderful gift that no one else can give you. That is why monks will seal themselves into caves for years to get rid of distractions. Unfortunatly they take the distractions in with them and that is what they must overcome. You do not need to be sealed into a cave, you just need to learn to empty your mind of all thought and feelings and it will come. I have been there and it is impossible to describe. Everyone has the ability to reach it but you must let go and open up your mind. Don't train your mind to believe it can do anything as this is the complete opposite and will keep you from attaining oneness. Don't let them win, the stakes are too high.

Anyone that tells you to live for the moment and forget the rest is not only deceiving you but they are deceiving themselves as well. You may ask why Mara and the rest would want to stop you from gaining nirvana, it is because they can't and they know it and they don't want you to gain it either because they are the embodiment of all that is wrong with the world. If they can deceive you and keep you from the truth then you will be destroyed with them.

The american indians tell a tale of the world being destroyed and reborn. It has happened 4 times and the 5th is upon us soon. How many times has a jealous lover killed the one that spurned their love, so that person would not be happy with another. It is the same principal that the evil ones are doing, they don't want you to be happy because they know they will not be allowed to survive the destruction. So they are trying to take as many with them as they can.

This is the central theme in many religions, so just ask yourself, Why is that? It is because GOD/UNIVERSE is trying to get the message out to people through prophets and saints. However the message is getting distorted by those who want you to fail. Make up your own mind and don't let them persuade you differently.


answered 25 Jun '10, 19:13

Goodisevil's gravatar image



This is the second time on this site that I have heard this idea of evil beings (and from the description, I am obviously one of them!) that are teaching people how to realize their potential as a way of tricking them into some horrible fate. So, I'll ask you the same question that I asked the previous proponent of this idea (and didn't receive an answer) which is... Don't you think it is rather self-defeating for evil beings (such as myself!) to teach self-empowerment if the ultimate goal is dis-empowerment? Do you not see a contradiction here?

(25 Jun '10, 21:51) Stingray

OK..So let me get this correct. When you murder the innocent it's OK?, When you rape, it's OK?, when you bear false witness, it's ok. I'm not understanding how all of these things are OK. Somebody please enlighten me. Thanks

(26 Jun '10, 20:16) GS415

@GS415 - No-one who is feeling good about themselves would want to engage in any of those behaviors. All those reactions come from a place of feeling dis-empowered. Think about it in your own life - when is the time when you do harmful things you later regret...when you are feeling good, or when you are feeling bad? So many of the apparent problems in the world stem from people feeling dis-empowered.

(27 Jun '10, 08:14) Stingray

To realize your potential stingray is to let go of everything and not fill your mind with any set values or clutter. You must open your self to the universe and let it enlighten your mind and spirit. As for you GS415, I never said it was OK to hurt others. You must clear your mind of all thoughts and feelings and let the universe fill it with something so wonderful I can not begin to describe it here. And yes stingray there are forces out there to keep you from realizing your true potential. They want you to be preoccupied with anything but the truth, and the truth will set you free.

(03 Jul '10, 20:35) Goodisevil

each decision we choose takes us towards or away from 'the light'. by nature we have pressure as we do from spirit. those who have no choice (will) are deceitful and envious of those with creative spirit. and there is reciprocal effect in all choices made

(04 Sep '12, 08:50) fred
showing 2 of 5 show 3 more comments

And I agree with both of you. The process that wildlife has described is correct but karma does play a role. You get to choose but you have that karmic baggage over you and you are forced to take it into consideration.
The purpose of reincarnation is the development of the spirit. There are many obstacles in material world (unlike in the afterlife) which make it easier to grow. This is the role of the evil things. They teach us. We are given the occasion to overcome the hurdles and improve ourselves. Eventually there will be nothing to work on and we won't leave karmic footprints anymore. We will become perfect and unite with God.


answered 25 Jun '10, 20:14

Asklepios's gravatar image


it does not matter of religion
our feeble attempt to control
does not tell nature what to do
her laws are immutable

what you intellect starts
ejects a force out from you
yet within the rule of her
law of homogenous species

it gathers with like kind
and then returns to be
balanced to original
design, divinely willed


answered 15 Jun '12, 21:41

fred's gravatar image


According to the Law of Attraction, we are attracted to and attract to us things and people and events and circumstances that match our vibration. So whatever vibration we put out, is what we get back. If we put out negative vibrations, we get matching negative experiences. This is not punishment, but has been misunderstood as punishment and has been called karma, the wrath of God, etc... Like if you put your hand on a hot stove and get burned, you are not being punished by anybody, that is just the logical consequence of touching a hot stove. If a person jumps off a bridge, gravity takes them down, not punishment. So logically, when we get what we put out vibrationally, it is not punishment, just the LOA.

When we are born, we are attracted to our family by our vibrations and our family's vibration. That is our starting point. We have a choice to choose thoughts and beliefs that will raise our vibration, keep it the same or lower it. The goal is to raise our vibration. When we leave these physical bodies, our soul is attracted to it's next destination by our vibration. This can be seen as going to heaven or hell, depending on our vibration. Maybe we come back as an animal or plant or maybe another human with another opportunity to raise or lower our vibration. Love raises our vibration and fear lowers it.

So reincarnation isn't Karmic in the sense that people have made it out to be as reward and punishment, but it is simply the LOA at work.


answered 03 Sep '12, 14:06

Fairy%20Princess's gravatar image

Fairy Princess

fairy princess, reincarnation could be cyclical depending on our active spiritual inclination to experience more consciousness. then there are laws of nature such as movement, gravity, homogenious species and attraction. all having or applying guidelines and pressure to our will. pure and harmless actions beget like, yet not necessarily in the same earth life.

(03 Sep '12, 20:14) fred

As long as we hold a particular vibration, we attract accordingly. If we take that vibration to another life, we attract according to that vibration. If you want to change what you are attracting, change your vibration.

(04 Sep '12, 08:24) Fairy Princess

I am a hindu and know the laws of karma intimately. There is 'Paap' and 'Punya' -- Paap is evil deeds and Punya are pious deeds. According to karma we are supposed to get the fruits of our actions right here on this earth. So if you do Paap you'll get punishment and if you do Punya you will get rewards. If you do either of it you're still entangled in trapped in Maya(illusion) -- The only way to attain nirvana is to leave Maya behind and seek the ultimate being and him alone and not any demigods this will free you from the cycle of millions of births and deaths.

I personally think we're just are just animals that have gotten really smart and after that we're just being plain elitist about the whole thing. We're doing to nature what Racists do to the rest of humanity, divide things and have an us vs them mentality. When the Britishers had their empire they had a theory of 'White Mans Burden' - Now the Americans have a similar theory. We as a species have a similar mindset as well -- save the earth. Its ridiculous, I am betting the earth will still out-survive the extinction of the human species. So, we're just kidding ourselves.

I also think there is no proof of either Karma or Life after birth.

While karma sounds good -- I still think there is nothing know as the soul you and me are just beings created by the genes for its own propagation - 2 core aims in life that are biologically imprinted on every being are :

1. Survival
2. Reproduction

Your body and mind are geared for these 2 concepts. So even the religious part of your brain exists because it was evolutionarily advantageous. I think it has served us well. You'll see through the times of history - god's changed, prayers changed, theories changed, but, one constant was the existence of religion.

Understand we(humans) have been here for quite a few thousand years not because of some 2000-4000 year old god - but because our early ancestors took the right path in the survival game. Because we conquered nature and triumphed over the other animals. Point is - When you're over, your game's going to be over. Live while you can.

Second, about karma - I seriously don't think there is any karma. There is just the environment(everything outside you) and how you interact with it. There is no reward or punishment. There are just choices and those choices have consequences -- some you can predict - others you can't. So, seek to understand the world around you. Don't take the most basic concepts you learn about at their face value. question everything.


answered 26 Jun '10, 10:14

xyz's gravatar image


edited 26 Jun '10, 10:19


I'm just curious DMin. I like what you said in your last paragraph. However, in your opening paragraph you say that you're a Hindu and know the laws of Karma intimately, pertaining to the laws of Hinduism. If you believe what you wrote in your last paragraph then why are you a Hindu? I'm just trying to understand why you would follow a religion if you don't believe in all it's teachings - no offence meant.

(26 Jun '10, 14:58) Michaela

This is a great question. I respect all the replies given and wish to share my own perspective to this question.

As eternal sovereign beings in this Universal construct, we are organically intented to incarnate not reincarnate. The word reincarnation denotes a recyling process of incarnation, and this recycling process most certainly denotes the false-light construct we call karma. Those who believe in karma or who are blissfully unaware of it, will, after leaving one's physical vehicle, recycle back into the reincarnational Matrix programme to potentially acheive balance in their belief system of positive and negative as pertains to their incarnational existences.

The problem with this system is that one will continually attempt -- via (re)incarnation -- to achieve a positive balance or negative balance in one's next linear incarnation in relation to one's prior linear incarnation, continuing the incarnational recycling programme, and completely missing the point of the Divine Neutral: that both positive and negative energies exist concurrently; that contrast is awareness; and that integration and inclusion of these contrasting polarities is what expands us as eternal sovereign beings on the verge of becoming Universal Creators. Many of us have already achieved what we needed to achieve long ago (in linear terms), but remain stuck in this process. And there are two reasons for this.

Spiritually, we made a contract (in linear terms) long, long ago with a Soul Group Consciousness that would serve as a catalyst to provide a contrast to our natural state of being, which is Love and Light and Connection to All There Is. This was done so that we would grow in awareness of what we are via the limiting illusion of what we are not, provided by the catalyst.

The further problem is that this Soul Group Consciousness that was to provide a catalyst for our growth got so caught up and enjoyed its various roles of domination and control over us, that it eventually breached the original contract and continued the role of domination and control without our consent. As we agreed to be initially 'vulnerable' and exposed to 'limitations', we, in turn, forgot who we were, what are powers are, and what the initial contract was. This Soul Group Consciousness took advantage of the 'situation', and continues to do so. And this applies to when our consciousness leaves our Earthly vehicle at 'death'.

The veil is NOT lifted after our physical 'death'. It is and has for a long time been fully in place, but on another level of manipulation. The 'Heaven' scenario is an artificial light construct perpetrated by those entities who wish us to continue to believe in the Wheel of Karma, so that we will continually reincarnate over and over into the same paradigm of soul fractal entrapment.


answered 14 May '14, 23:20

TGunn's gravatar image


edited 15 May '14, 21:23

Click here to create a free account

If you are seeing this message then the Inward Quest system has noticed that your web browser is behaving in an unusual way and is now blocking your active participation in this site for security reasons. As a result, among other things, you may find that you are unable to answer any questions or leave any comments. Unusual browser behavior is often caused by add-ons (ad-blocking, privacy etc) that interfere with the operation of our website. If you have installed these kinds of add-ons, we suggest you disable them for this website

Related Questions